Cargando…

The Impact of the Addition of a Virtual Reality Trainer on Skill Retention of Tourniquet Application for Hemorrhage Control Among Emergency Medical Technician Students: A Pilot Study

Introduction: Trauma is a leading cause of preventable death in the United States. Emergency Medical Technicians (EMTs) often arrive first at the scene of traumatic injuries to perform life-saving skills such as tourniquet placement. While current EMT courses teach and test tourniquet application, s...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Arif, Adeel, Santana Felipes, Rachel C, Hoxhaj, Mia, Light, Michael B, Dadario, Nicholas B, Cook, Brennan, Cataldo, Matthew J, Jafri, Farrukh N
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Cureus 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9971574/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36865981
http://dx.doi.org/10.7759/cureus.34320
_version_ 1784898127695708160
author Arif, Adeel
Santana Felipes, Rachel C
Hoxhaj, Mia
Light, Michael B
Dadario, Nicholas B
Cook, Brennan
Cataldo, Matthew J
Jafri, Farrukh N
author_facet Arif, Adeel
Santana Felipes, Rachel C
Hoxhaj, Mia
Light, Michael B
Dadario, Nicholas B
Cook, Brennan
Cataldo, Matthew J
Jafri, Farrukh N
author_sort Arif, Adeel
collection PubMed
description Introduction: Trauma is a leading cause of preventable death in the United States. Emergency Medical Technicians (EMTs) often arrive first at the scene of traumatic injuries to perform life-saving skills such as tourniquet placement. While current EMT courses teach and test tourniquet application, studies have shown efficacy and retention of EMT skills such as tourniquet placement decay over time, with educational interventions needed to improve retention of skills. Methods: A prospective randomized pilot study was conducted to determine differences in retention of tourniquet placement among 40 EMT students after initial training. Participants were randomly assigned to either a virtual reality (VR) intervention or a control group. The VR group received instruction from a refresher VR program 35 days after initial training as a supplement to their EMT course. Both the VR and control participants’ tourniquet skills were assessed 70 days after initial training by blinded instructors.  Results: There was no significant difference in correct tourniquet placement between both groups (Control, 63% vs Intervention, 57%, p = 0.57). It was found that 9/21 participants (43%) in the VR intervention group failed to correctly apply the tourniquet while 7/19 of the control participants (37%) failed in tourniquet application. Additionally, the VR group was more likely to fail the tourniquet application due to improper tightening than the control group during the final assessment (p = 0.04).  Conclusion: In this pilot study, using a VR headset in conjunction with in-person training did not improve the efficacy and retention of tourniquet placement skills. Participants who received the VR intervention were more likely to have errors relating to haptics, rather than procedure-related errors.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9971574
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher Cureus
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-99715742023-03-01 The Impact of the Addition of a Virtual Reality Trainer on Skill Retention of Tourniquet Application for Hemorrhage Control Among Emergency Medical Technician Students: A Pilot Study Arif, Adeel Santana Felipes, Rachel C Hoxhaj, Mia Light, Michael B Dadario, Nicholas B Cook, Brennan Cataldo, Matthew J Jafri, Farrukh N Cureus Medical Education Introduction: Trauma is a leading cause of preventable death in the United States. Emergency Medical Technicians (EMTs) often arrive first at the scene of traumatic injuries to perform life-saving skills such as tourniquet placement. While current EMT courses teach and test tourniquet application, studies have shown efficacy and retention of EMT skills such as tourniquet placement decay over time, with educational interventions needed to improve retention of skills. Methods: A prospective randomized pilot study was conducted to determine differences in retention of tourniquet placement among 40 EMT students after initial training. Participants were randomly assigned to either a virtual reality (VR) intervention or a control group. The VR group received instruction from a refresher VR program 35 days after initial training as a supplement to their EMT course. Both the VR and control participants’ tourniquet skills were assessed 70 days after initial training by blinded instructors.  Results: There was no significant difference in correct tourniquet placement between both groups (Control, 63% vs Intervention, 57%, p = 0.57). It was found that 9/21 participants (43%) in the VR intervention group failed to correctly apply the tourniquet while 7/19 of the control participants (37%) failed in tourniquet application. Additionally, the VR group was more likely to fail the tourniquet application due to improper tightening than the control group during the final assessment (p = 0.04).  Conclusion: In this pilot study, using a VR headset in conjunction with in-person training did not improve the efficacy and retention of tourniquet placement skills. Participants who received the VR intervention were more likely to have errors relating to haptics, rather than procedure-related errors. Cureus 2023-01-28 /pmc/articles/PMC9971574/ /pubmed/36865981 http://dx.doi.org/10.7759/cureus.34320 Text en Copyright © 2023, Arif et al. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
spellingShingle Medical Education
Arif, Adeel
Santana Felipes, Rachel C
Hoxhaj, Mia
Light, Michael B
Dadario, Nicholas B
Cook, Brennan
Cataldo, Matthew J
Jafri, Farrukh N
The Impact of the Addition of a Virtual Reality Trainer on Skill Retention of Tourniquet Application for Hemorrhage Control Among Emergency Medical Technician Students: A Pilot Study
title The Impact of the Addition of a Virtual Reality Trainer on Skill Retention of Tourniquet Application for Hemorrhage Control Among Emergency Medical Technician Students: A Pilot Study
title_full The Impact of the Addition of a Virtual Reality Trainer on Skill Retention of Tourniquet Application for Hemorrhage Control Among Emergency Medical Technician Students: A Pilot Study
title_fullStr The Impact of the Addition of a Virtual Reality Trainer on Skill Retention of Tourniquet Application for Hemorrhage Control Among Emergency Medical Technician Students: A Pilot Study
title_full_unstemmed The Impact of the Addition of a Virtual Reality Trainer on Skill Retention of Tourniquet Application for Hemorrhage Control Among Emergency Medical Technician Students: A Pilot Study
title_short The Impact of the Addition of a Virtual Reality Trainer on Skill Retention of Tourniquet Application for Hemorrhage Control Among Emergency Medical Technician Students: A Pilot Study
title_sort impact of the addition of a virtual reality trainer on skill retention of tourniquet application for hemorrhage control among emergency medical technician students: a pilot study
topic Medical Education
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9971574/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36865981
http://dx.doi.org/10.7759/cureus.34320
work_keys_str_mv AT arifadeel theimpactoftheadditionofavirtualrealitytraineronskillretentionoftourniquetapplicationforhemorrhagecontrolamongemergencymedicaltechnicianstudentsapilotstudy
AT santanafelipesrachelc theimpactoftheadditionofavirtualrealitytraineronskillretentionoftourniquetapplicationforhemorrhagecontrolamongemergencymedicaltechnicianstudentsapilotstudy
AT hoxhajmia theimpactoftheadditionofavirtualrealitytraineronskillretentionoftourniquetapplicationforhemorrhagecontrolamongemergencymedicaltechnicianstudentsapilotstudy
AT lightmichaelb theimpactoftheadditionofavirtualrealitytraineronskillretentionoftourniquetapplicationforhemorrhagecontrolamongemergencymedicaltechnicianstudentsapilotstudy
AT dadarionicholasb theimpactoftheadditionofavirtualrealitytraineronskillretentionoftourniquetapplicationforhemorrhagecontrolamongemergencymedicaltechnicianstudentsapilotstudy
AT cookbrennan theimpactoftheadditionofavirtualrealitytraineronskillretentionoftourniquetapplicationforhemorrhagecontrolamongemergencymedicaltechnicianstudentsapilotstudy
AT cataldomatthewj theimpactoftheadditionofavirtualrealitytraineronskillretentionoftourniquetapplicationforhemorrhagecontrolamongemergencymedicaltechnicianstudentsapilotstudy
AT jafrifarrukhn theimpactoftheadditionofavirtualrealitytraineronskillretentionoftourniquetapplicationforhemorrhagecontrolamongemergencymedicaltechnicianstudentsapilotstudy
AT arifadeel impactoftheadditionofavirtualrealitytraineronskillretentionoftourniquetapplicationforhemorrhagecontrolamongemergencymedicaltechnicianstudentsapilotstudy
AT santanafelipesrachelc impactoftheadditionofavirtualrealitytraineronskillretentionoftourniquetapplicationforhemorrhagecontrolamongemergencymedicaltechnicianstudentsapilotstudy
AT hoxhajmia impactoftheadditionofavirtualrealitytraineronskillretentionoftourniquetapplicationforhemorrhagecontrolamongemergencymedicaltechnicianstudentsapilotstudy
AT lightmichaelb impactoftheadditionofavirtualrealitytraineronskillretentionoftourniquetapplicationforhemorrhagecontrolamongemergencymedicaltechnicianstudentsapilotstudy
AT dadarionicholasb impactoftheadditionofavirtualrealitytraineronskillretentionoftourniquetapplicationforhemorrhagecontrolamongemergencymedicaltechnicianstudentsapilotstudy
AT cookbrennan impactoftheadditionofavirtualrealitytraineronskillretentionoftourniquetapplicationforhemorrhagecontrolamongemergencymedicaltechnicianstudentsapilotstudy
AT cataldomatthewj impactoftheadditionofavirtualrealitytraineronskillretentionoftourniquetapplicationforhemorrhagecontrolamongemergencymedicaltechnicianstudentsapilotstudy
AT jafrifarrukhn impactoftheadditionofavirtualrealitytraineronskillretentionoftourniquetapplicationforhemorrhagecontrolamongemergencymedicaltechnicianstudentsapilotstudy