Cargando…

The impact of “freedom day” on COVID-19 health protective behaviour in England: An observational study of hand hygiene, face covering use and physical distancing in public spaces pre and post the relaxing of restrictions

OBJECTIVES: To study the prevalence of COVID-19 health protective behaviours before and after rules eased in England on the 19(th) July 2021. DESIGN: Observational study pre (12(th)-18(th) July) and post (26(th) July-1(st) August) 19(th) July, and a cross-sectional online survey (26(th) to 27(th) Ju...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Davies, Rachel, Martin, Alex F, Smith, Louise E, Mowbray, Fiona, Woodland, Lisa, Amlôt, Richard, Rubin, G James
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: SAGE Publications 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9989406/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36895854
http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/20542704231153563
_version_ 1784901760075169792
author Davies, Rachel
Martin, Alex F
Smith, Louise E
Mowbray, Fiona
Woodland, Lisa
Amlôt, Richard
Rubin, G James
author_facet Davies, Rachel
Martin, Alex F
Smith, Louise E
Mowbray, Fiona
Woodland, Lisa
Amlôt, Richard
Rubin, G James
author_sort Davies, Rachel
collection PubMed
description OBJECTIVES: To study the prevalence of COVID-19 health protective behaviours before and after rules eased in England on the 19(th) July 2021. DESIGN: Observational study pre (12(th)-18(th) July) and post (26(th) July-1(st) August) 19(th) July, and a cross-sectional online survey (26(th) to 27(th) July). SETTING: Observations occurred in supermarkets (n = 10), train stations (n = 10), bus stops (n = 10), a coach station (n = 1) and a London Underground station (n = 1). The survey recruited a nationally representative sample. PARTICIPANTS: All adults entering the observed locations during a one-hour period (n = 3819 pre- and n = 2948 post-19(th) July). In the online survey, 1472 respondents reported having been shopping for groceries/visited a pharmacy and 566 reported having used public transport or having been in a taxi/minicab in the last week. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: We observed whether people wore a face covering, maintained distance from others and cleaned their hands. We investigated self-reports of wearing a face covering while in shops or using public transport. RESULTS: In most locations observed, the proportion of people wearing face coverings, cleaning the hands and maintaining physical distance declined post 19th July. Pre 19(th) July, 70.2% (95% CI 68.7 to 71.7%) of people were observed to be wearing a face covering versus 55.8% (54.2 to 57.9%) post 19(th) July. Equivalent rates for physical distancing were 40.9% (39.0 to 42.8%) versus 29.5% (27.4 to 31.7%), and for hand hygiene were 4.4% (3.8 to 5.1%) versus 3.9% (3.2 to 4.6%). Self-reports of “always” wearing face coverings were broadly similar to observed rates. CONCLUSIONS: Adherence to protective behaviours was sub-optimal and declined during the relaxation of restrictions, despite appeals to exercise caution. Self-reports of “always” wearing a face covering in specific locations appear valid.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9989406
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher SAGE Publications
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-99894062023-03-08 The impact of “freedom day” on COVID-19 health protective behaviour in England: An observational study of hand hygiene, face covering use and physical distancing in public spaces pre and post the relaxing of restrictions Davies, Rachel Martin, Alex F Smith, Louise E Mowbray, Fiona Woodland, Lisa Amlôt, Richard Rubin, G James JRSM Open Research Paper OBJECTIVES: To study the prevalence of COVID-19 health protective behaviours before and after rules eased in England on the 19(th) July 2021. DESIGN: Observational study pre (12(th)-18(th) July) and post (26(th) July-1(st) August) 19(th) July, and a cross-sectional online survey (26(th) to 27(th) July). SETTING: Observations occurred in supermarkets (n = 10), train stations (n = 10), bus stops (n = 10), a coach station (n = 1) and a London Underground station (n = 1). The survey recruited a nationally representative sample. PARTICIPANTS: All adults entering the observed locations during a one-hour period (n = 3819 pre- and n = 2948 post-19(th) July). In the online survey, 1472 respondents reported having been shopping for groceries/visited a pharmacy and 566 reported having used public transport or having been in a taxi/minicab in the last week. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: We observed whether people wore a face covering, maintained distance from others and cleaned their hands. We investigated self-reports of wearing a face covering while in shops or using public transport. RESULTS: In most locations observed, the proportion of people wearing face coverings, cleaning the hands and maintaining physical distance declined post 19th July. Pre 19(th) July, 70.2% (95% CI 68.7 to 71.7%) of people were observed to be wearing a face covering versus 55.8% (54.2 to 57.9%) post 19(th) July. Equivalent rates for physical distancing were 40.9% (39.0 to 42.8%) versus 29.5% (27.4 to 31.7%), and for hand hygiene were 4.4% (3.8 to 5.1%) versus 3.9% (3.2 to 4.6%). Self-reports of “always” wearing face coverings were broadly similar to observed rates. CONCLUSIONS: Adherence to protective behaviours was sub-optimal and declined during the relaxation of restrictions, despite appeals to exercise caution. Self-reports of “always” wearing a face covering in specific locations appear valid. SAGE Publications 2023-03-06 /pmc/articles/PMC9989406/ /pubmed/36895854 http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/20542704231153563 Text en © 2023 The Author(s) https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/) which permits non-commercial use, reproduction and distribution of the work without further permission provided the original work is attributed as specified on the SAGE and Open Access page (https://us.sagepub.com/en-us/nam/open-access-at-sage).
spellingShingle Research Paper
Davies, Rachel
Martin, Alex F
Smith, Louise E
Mowbray, Fiona
Woodland, Lisa
Amlôt, Richard
Rubin, G James
The impact of “freedom day” on COVID-19 health protective behaviour in England: An observational study of hand hygiene, face covering use and physical distancing in public spaces pre and post the relaxing of restrictions
title The impact of “freedom day” on COVID-19 health protective behaviour in England: An observational study of hand hygiene, face covering use and physical distancing in public spaces pre and post the relaxing of restrictions
title_full The impact of “freedom day” on COVID-19 health protective behaviour in England: An observational study of hand hygiene, face covering use and physical distancing in public spaces pre and post the relaxing of restrictions
title_fullStr The impact of “freedom day” on COVID-19 health protective behaviour in England: An observational study of hand hygiene, face covering use and physical distancing in public spaces pre and post the relaxing of restrictions
title_full_unstemmed The impact of “freedom day” on COVID-19 health protective behaviour in England: An observational study of hand hygiene, face covering use and physical distancing in public spaces pre and post the relaxing of restrictions
title_short The impact of “freedom day” on COVID-19 health protective behaviour in England: An observational study of hand hygiene, face covering use and physical distancing in public spaces pre and post the relaxing of restrictions
title_sort impact of “freedom day” on covid-19 health protective behaviour in england: an observational study of hand hygiene, face covering use and physical distancing in public spaces pre and post the relaxing of restrictions
topic Research Paper
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9989406/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/36895854
http://dx.doi.org/10.1177/20542704231153563
work_keys_str_mv AT daviesrachel theimpactoffreedomdayoncovid19healthprotectivebehaviourinenglandanobservationalstudyofhandhygienefacecoveringuseandphysicaldistancinginpublicspacespreandposttherelaxingofrestrictions
AT martinalexf theimpactoffreedomdayoncovid19healthprotectivebehaviourinenglandanobservationalstudyofhandhygienefacecoveringuseandphysicaldistancinginpublicspacespreandposttherelaxingofrestrictions
AT smithlouisee theimpactoffreedomdayoncovid19healthprotectivebehaviourinenglandanobservationalstudyofhandhygienefacecoveringuseandphysicaldistancinginpublicspacespreandposttherelaxingofrestrictions
AT mowbrayfiona theimpactoffreedomdayoncovid19healthprotectivebehaviourinenglandanobservationalstudyofhandhygienefacecoveringuseandphysicaldistancinginpublicspacespreandposttherelaxingofrestrictions
AT woodlandlisa theimpactoffreedomdayoncovid19healthprotectivebehaviourinenglandanobservationalstudyofhandhygienefacecoveringuseandphysicaldistancinginpublicspacespreandposttherelaxingofrestrictions
AT amlotrichard theimpactoffreedomdayoncovid19healthprotectivebehaviourinenglandanobservationalstudyofhandhygienefacecoveringuseandphysicaldistancinginpublicspacespreandposttherelaxingofrestrictions
AT rubingjames theimpactoffreedomdayoncovid19healthprotectivebehaviourinenglandanobservationalstudyofhandhygienefacecoveringuseandphysicaldistancinginpublicspacespreandposttherelaxingofrestrictions
AT daviesrachel impactoffreedomdayoncovid19healthprotectivebehaviourinenglandanobservationalstudyofhandhygienefacecoveringuseandphysicaldistancinginpublicspacespreandposttherelaxingofrestrictions
AT martinalexf impactoffreedomdayoncovid19healthprotectivebehaviourinenglandanobservationalstudyofhandhygienefacecoveringuseandphysicaldistancinginpublicspacespreandposttherelaxingofrestrictions
AT smithlouisee impactoffreedomdayoncovid19healthprotectivebehaviourinenglandanobservationalstudyofhandhygienefacecoveringuseandphysicaldistancinginpublicspacespreandposttherelaxingofrestrictions
AT mowbrayfiona impactoffreedomdayoncovid19healthprotectivebehaviourinenglandanobservationalstudyofhandhygienefacecoveringuseandphysicaldistancinginpublicspacespreandposttherelaxingofrestrictions
AT woodlandlisa impactoffreedomdayoncovid19healthprotectivebehaviourinenglandanobservationalstudyofhandhygienefacecoveringuseandphysicaldistancinginpublicspacespreandposttherelaxingofrestrictions
AT amlotrichard impactoffreedomdayoncovid19healthprotectivebehaviourinenglandanobservationalstudyofhandhygienefacecoveringuseandphysicaldistancinginpublicspacespreandposttherelaxingofrestrictions
AT rubingjames impactoffreedomdayoncovid19healthprotectivebehaviourinenglandanobservationalstudyofhandhygienefacecoveringuseandphysicaldistancinginpublicspacespreandposttherelaxingofrestrictions