Cargando…
Measuring the Burden of Infodemics: Summary of the Methods and Results of the Fifth WHO Infodemic Management Conference
BACKGROUND: An infodemic is excess information, including false or misleading information, that spreads in digital and physical environments during a public health emergency. The COVID-19 pandemic has been accompanied by an unprecedented global infodemic that has led to confusion about the benefits...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
JMIR Publications
2023
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9989916/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37012998 http://dx.doi.org/10.2196/44207 |
_version_ | 1784901851510996992 |
---|---|
author | Wilhelm, Elisabeth Ballalai, Isabella Belanger, Marie-Eve Benjamin, Peter Bertrand-Ferrandis, Catherine Bezbaruah, Supriya Briand, Sylvie Brooks, Ian Bruns, Richard Bucci, Lucie M Calleja, Neville Chiou, Howard Devaria, Abhinav Dini, Lorena D'Souza, Hyjel Dunn, Adam G Eichstaedt, Johannes C Evers, Silvia M A A Gobat, Nina Gissler, Mika Gonzales, Ian Christian Gruzd, Anatoliy Hess, Sarah Ishizumi, Atsuyoshi John, Oommen Joshi, Ashish Kaluza, Benjamin Khamis, Nagwa Kosinska, Monika Kulkarni, Shibani Lingri, Dimitra Ludolph, Ramona Mackey, Tim Mandić-Rajčević, Stefan Menczer, Filippo Mudaliar, Vijaybabu Murthy, Shruti Nazakat, Syed Nguyen, Tim Nilsen, Jennifer Pallari, Elena Pasternak Taschner, Natalia Petelos, Elena Prinstein, Mitchell J Roozenbeek, Jon Schneider, Anton Srinivasan, Varadharajan Stevanović, Aleksandar Strahwald, Brigitte Syed Abdul, Shabbir Varaidzo Machiri, Sandra van der Linden, Sander Voegeli, Christopher Wardle, Claire Wegwarth, Odette White, Becky K Willie, Estelle Yau, Brian Purnat, Tina D |
author_facet | Wilhelm, Elisabeth Ballalai, Isabella Belanger, Marie-Eve Benjamin, Peter Bertrand-Ferrandis, Catherine Bezbaruah, Supriya Briand, Sylvie Brooks, Ian Bruns, Richard Bucci, Lucie M Calleja, Neville Chiou, Howard Devaria, Abhinav Dini, Lorena D'Souza, Hyjel Dunn, Adam G Eichstaedt, Johannes C Evers, Silvia M A A Gobat, Nina Gissler, Mika Gonzales, Ian Christian Gruzd, Anatoliy Hess, Sarah Ishizumi, Atsuyoshi John, Oommen Joshi, Ashish Kaluza, Benjamin Khamis, Nagwa Kosinska, Monika Kulkarni, Shibani Lingri, Dimitra Ludolph, Ramona Mackey, Tim Mandić-Rajčević, Stefan Menczer, Filippo Mudaliar, Vijaybabu Murthy, Shruti Nazakat, Syed Nguyen, Tim Nilsen, Jennifer Pallari, Elena Pasternak Taschner, Natalia Petelos, Elena Prinstein, Mitchell J Roozenbeek, Jon Schneider, Anton Srinivasan, Varadharajan Stevanović, Aleksandar Strahwald, Brigitte Syed Abdul, Shabbir Varaidzo Machiri, Sandra van der Linden, Sander Voegeli, Christopher Wardle, Claire Wegwarth, Odette White, Becky K Willie, Estelle Yau, Brian Purnat, Tina D |
author_sort | Wilhelm, Elisabeth |
collection | PubMed |
description | BACKGROUND: An infodemic is excess information, including false or misleading information, that spreads in digital and physical environments during a public health emergency. The COVID-19 pandemic has been accompanied by an unprecedented global infodemic that has led to confusion about the benefits of medical and public health interventions, with substantial impact on risk-taking and health-seeking behaviors, eroding trust in health authorities and compromising the effectiveness of public health responses and policies. Standardized measures are needed to quantify the harmful impacts of the infodemic in a systematic and methodologically robust manner, as well as harmonizing highly divergent approaches currently explored for this purpose. This can serve as a foundation for a systematic, evidence-based approach to monitoring, identifying, and mitigating future infodemic harms in emergency preparedness and prevention. OBJECTIVE: In this paper, we summarize the Fifth World Health Organization (WHO) Infodemic Management Conference structure, proceedings, outcomes, and proposed actions seeking to identify the interdisciplinary approaches and frameworks needed to enable the measurement of the burden of infodemics. METHODS: An iterative human-centered design (HCD) approach and concept mapping were used to facilitate focused discussions and allow for the generation of actionable outcomes and recommendations. The discussions included 86 participants representing diverse scientific disciplines and health authorities from 28 countries across all WHO regions, along with observers from civil society and global public health–implementing partners. A thematic map capturing the concepts matching the key contributing factors to the public health burden of infodemics was used throughout the conference to frame and contextualize discussions. Five key areas for immediate action were identified. RESULTS: The 5 key areas for the development of metrics to assess the burden of infodemics and associated interventions included (1) developing standardized definitions and ensuring the adoption thereof; (2) improving the map of concepts influencing the burden of infodemics; (3) conducting a review of evidence, tools, and data sources; (4) setting up a technical working group; and (5) addressing immediate priorities for postpandemic recovery and resilience building. The summary report consolidated group input toward a common vocabulary with standardized terms, concepts, study designs, measures, and tools to estimate the burden of infodemics and the effectiveness of infodemic management interventions. CONCLUSIONS: Standardizing measurement is the basis for documenting the burden of infodemics on health systems and population health during emergencies. Investment is needed into the development of practical, affordable, evidence-based, and systematic methods that are legally and ethically balanced for monitoring infodemics; generating diagnostics, infodemic insights, and recommendations; and developing interventions, action-oriented guidance, policies, support options, mechanisms, and tools for infodemic managers and emergency program managers. |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-9989916 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2023 |
publisher | JMIR Publications |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-99899162023-03-30 Measuring the Burden of Infodemics: Summary of the Methods and Results of the Fifth WHO Infodemic Management Conference Wilhelm, Elisabeth Ballalai, Isabella Belanger, Marie-Eve Benjamin, Peter Bertrand-Ferrandis, Catherine Bezbaruah, Supriya Briand, Sylvie Brooks, Ian Bruns, Richard Bucci, Lucie M Calleja, Neville Chiou, Howard Devaria, Abhinav Dini, Lorena D'Souza, Hyjel Dunn, Adam G Eichstaedt, Johannes C Evers, Silvia M A A Gobat, Nina Gissler, Mika Gonzales, Ian Christian Gruzd, Anatoliy Hess, Sarah Ishizumi, Atsuyoshi John, Oommen Joshi, Ashish Kaluza, Benjamin Khamis, Nagwa Kosinska, Monika Kulkarni, Shibani Lingri, Dimitra Ludolph, Ramona Mackey, Tim Mandić-Rajčević, Stefan Menczer, Filippo Mudaliar, Vijaybabu Murthy, Shruti Nazakat, Syed Nguyen, Tim Nilsen, Jennifer Pallari, Elena Pasternak Taschner, Natalia Petelos, Elena Prinstein, Mitchell J Roozenbeek, Jon Schneider, Anton Srinivasan, Varadharajan Stevanović, Aleksandar Strahwald, Brigitte Syed Abdul, Shabbir Varaidzo Machiri, Sandra van der Linden, Sander Voegeli, Christopher Wardle, Claire Wegwarth, Odette White, Becky K Willie, Estelle Yau, Brian Purnat, Tina D JMIR Infodemiology Original Paper BACKGROUND: An infodemic is excess information, including false or misleading information, that spreads in digital and physical environments during a public health emergency. The COVID-19 pandemic has been accompanied by an unprecedented global infodemic that has led to confusion about the benefits of medical and public health interventions, with substantial impact on risk-taking and health-seeking behaviors, eroding trust in health authorities and compromising the effectiveness of public health responses and policies. Standardized measures are needed to quantify the harmful impacts of the infodemic in a systematic and methodologically robust manner, as well as harmonizing highly divergent approaches currently explored for this purpose. This can serve as a foundation for a systematic, evidence-based approach to monitoring, identifying, and mitigating future infodemic harms in emergency preparedness and prevention. OBJECTIVE: In this paper, we summarize the Fifth World Health Organization (WHO) Infodemic Management Conference structure, proceedings, outcomes, and proposed actions seeking to identify the interdisciplinary approaches and frameworks needed to enable the measurement of the burden of infodemics. METHODS: An iterative human-centered design (HCD) approach and concept mapping were used to facilitate focused discussions and allow for the generation of actionable outcomes and recommendations. The discussions included 86 participants representing diverse scientific disciplines and health authorities from 28 countries across all WHO regions, along with observers from civil society and global public health–implementing partners. A thematic map capturing the concepts matching the key contributing factors to the public health burden of infodemics was used throughout the conference to frame and contextualize discussions. Five key areas for immediate action were identified. RESULTS: The 5 key areas for the development of metrics to assess the burden of infodemics and associated interventions included (1) developing standardized definitions and ensuring the adoption thereof; (2) improving the map of concepts influencing the burden of infodemics; (3) conducting a review of evidence, tools, and data sources; (4) setting up a technical working group; and (5) addressing immediate priorities for postpandemic recovery and resilience building. The summary report consolidated group input toward a common vocabulary with standardized terms, concepts, study designs, measures, and tools to estimate the burden of infodemics and the effectiveness of infodemic management interventions. CONCLUSIONS: Standardizing measurement is the basis for documenting the burden of infodemics on health systems and population health during emergencies. Investment is needed into the development of practical, affordable, evidence-based, and systematic methods that are legally and ethically balanced for monitoring infodemics; generating diagnostics, infodemic insights, and recommendations; and developing interventions, action-oriented guidance, policies, support options, mechanisms, and tools for infodemic managers and emergency program managers. JMIR Publications 2023-02-20 /pmc/articles/PMC9989916/ /pubmed/37012998 http://dx.doi.org/10.2196/44207 Text en ©Elisabeth Wilhelm, Isabella Ballalai, Marie-Eve Belanger, Peter Benjamin, Catherine Bertrand-Ferrandis, Supriya Bezbaruah, Sylvie Briand, Ian Brooks, Richard Bruns, Lucie M Bucci, Neville Calleja, Howard Chiou, Abhinav Devaria, Lorena Dini, Hyjel D'Souza, Adam G Dunn, Johannes C Eichstaedt, Silvia M A A Evers, Nina Gobat, Mika Gissler, Ian Christian Gonzales, Anatoliy Gruzd, Sarah Hess, Atsuyoshi Ishizumi, Oommen John, Ashish Joshi, Benjamin Kaluza, Nagwa Khamis, Monika Kosinska, Shibani Kulkarni, Dimitra Lingri, Ramona Ludolph, Tim Mackey, Stefan Mandić-Rajčević, Filippo Menczer, Vijaybabu Mudaliar, Shruti Murthy, Syed Nazakat, Tim Nguyen, Jennifer Nilsen, Elena Pallari, Natalia Pasternak Taschner, Elena Petelos, Mitchell J Prinstein, Jon Roozenbeek, Anton Schneider, Varadharajan Srinivasan, Aleksandar Stevanović, Brigitte Strahwald, Shabbir Syed Abdul, Sandra Varaidzo Machiri, Sander van der Linden, Christopher Voegeli, Claire Wardle, Odette Wegwarth, Becky K White, Estelle Willie, Brian Yau, Tina D Purnat. Originally published in JMIR Infodemiology (https://infodemiology.jmir.org), 20.02.2023. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work, first published in JMIR Infodemiology, is properly cited. The complete bibliographic information, a link to the original publication on https://infodemiology.jmir.org/, as well as this copyright and license information must be included. |
spellingShingle | Original Paper Wilhelm, Elisabeth Ballalai, Isabella Belanger, Marie-Eve Benjamin, Peter Bertrand-Ferrandis, Catherine Bezbaruah, Supriya Briand, Sylvie Brooks, Ian Bruns, Richard Bucci, Lucie M Calleja, Neville Chiou, Howard Devaria, Abhinav Dini, Lorena D'Souza, Hyjel Dunn, Adam G Eichstaedt, Johannes C Evers, Silvia M A A Gobat, Nina Gissler, Mika Gonzales, Ian Christian Gruzd, Anatoliy Hess, Sarah Ishizumi, Atsuyoshi John, Oommen Joshi, Ashish Kaluza, Benjamin Khamis, Nagwa Kosinska, Monika Kulkarni, Shibani Lingri, Dimitra Ludolph, Ramona Mackey, Tim Mandić-Rajčević, Stefan Menczer, Filippo Mudaliar, Vijaybabu Murthy, Shruti Nazakat, Syed Nguyen, Tim Nilsen, Jennifer Pallari, Elena Pasternak Taschner, Natalia Petelos, Elena Prinstein, Mitchell J Roozenbeek, Jon Schneider, Anton Srinivasan, Varadharajan Stevanović, Aleksandar Strahwald, Brigitte Syed Abdul, Shabbir Varaidzo Machiri, Sandra van der Linden, Sander Voegeli, Christopher Wardle, Claire Wegwarth, Odette White, Becky K Willie, Estelle Yau, Brian Purnat, Tina D Measuring the Burden of Infodemics: Summary of the Methods and Results of the Fifth WHO Infodemic Management Conference |
title | Measuring the Burden of Infodemics: Summary of the Methods and Results of the Fifth WHO Infodemic Management Conference |
title_full | Measuring the Burden of Infodemics: Summary of the Methods and Results of the Fifth WHO Infodemic Management Conference |
title_fullStr | Measuring the Burden of Infodemics: Summary of the Methods and Results of the Fifth WHO Infodemic Management Conference |
title_full_unstemmed | Measuring the Burden of Infodemics: Summary of the Methods and Results of the Fifth WHO Infodemic Management Conference |
title_short | Measuring the Burden of Infodemics: Summary of the Methods and Results of the Fifth WHO Infodemic Management Conference |
title_sort | measuring the burden of infodemics: summary of the methods and results of the fifth who infodemic management conference |
topic | Original Paper |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9989916/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37012998 http://dx.doi.org/10.2196/44207 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT wilhelmelisabeth measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT ballalaiisabella measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT belangermarieeve measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT benjaminpeter measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT bertrandferrandiscatherine measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT bezbaruahsupriya measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT briandsylvie measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT brooksian measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT brunsrichard measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT bucciluciem measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT callejaneville measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT chiouhoward measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT devariaabhinav measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT dinilorena measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT dsouzahyjel measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT dunnadamg measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT eichstaedtjohannesc measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT everssilviamaa measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT gobatnina measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT gisslermika measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT gonzalesianchristian measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT gruzdanatoliy measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT hesssarah measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT ishizumiatsuyoshi measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT johnoommen measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT joshiashish measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT kaluzabenjamin measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT khamisnagwa measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT kosinskamonika measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT kulkarnishibani measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT lingridimitra measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT ludolphramona measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT mackeytim measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT mandicrajcevicstefan measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT menczerfilippo measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT mudaliarvijaybabu measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT murthyshruti measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT nazakatsyed measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT nguyentim measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT nilsenjennifer measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT pallarielena measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT pasternaktaschnernatalia measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT peteloselena measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT prinsteinmitchellj measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT roozenbeekjon measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT schneideranton measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT srinivasanvaradharajan measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT stevanovicaleksandar measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT strahwaldbrigitte measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT syedabdulshabbir measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT varaidzomachirisandra measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT vanderlindensander measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT voegelichristopher measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT wardleclaire measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT wegwarthodette measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT whitebeckyk measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT willieestelle measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT yaubrian measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference AT purnattinad measuringtheburdenofinfodemicssummaryofthemethodsandresultsofthefifthwhoinfodemicmanagementconference |