Cargando…
A123 COMPARING SIZE MEASUREMENT OF SIMULATED COLORECTAL POLYPS WHEN USING A NOVEL VIRTUAL SCALE ENDOSCOPE, ENDOSCOPIC RULER OR FORCEPS: A BLINDED RANDOMIZED TRIAL
BACKGROUND: Accurate polyp size measurement is important for guideline conforming choice of polypectomy techniques and subsequent surveillance interval assignments. Some endoscopic tools (forceps or endoscopic rulers [ER]) exist to help with visual size estimation. A virtual scale endoscope (VSE) ha...
Autores principales: | , , , , , , , , |
---|---|
Formato: | Online Artículo Texto |
Lenguaje: | English |
Publicado: |
Oxford University Press
2023
|
Materias: | |
Acceso en línea: | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9991382/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/jcag/gwac036.123 |
_version_ | 1784902144154927104 |
---|---|
author | Djinbachian, R Taghiakbari, M Haumesser, C Zarandi-Nowroozi, M Abou-Khalil, M Sidani, S Liu, J Panzini, B von Renteln, D |
author_facet | Djinbachian, R Taghiakbari, M Haumesser, C Zarandi-Nowroozi, M Abou-Khalil, M Sidani, S Liu, J Panzini, B von Renteln, D |
author_sort | Djinbachian, R |
collection | PubMed |
description | BACKGROUND: Accurate polyp size measurement is important for guideline conforming choice of polypectomy techniques and subsequent surveillance interval assignments. Some endoscopic tools (forceps or endoscopic rulers [ER]) exist to help with visual size estimation. A virtual scale endoscope (VSE) has been developed that allows superimposing a virtual measurement scale during live endoscopies. PURPOSE: Our aim was to evaluate the performance of VSE when compared to ER and forceps-based measurement. METHOD: We conducted a randomized trial to evaluate the relative accuracy of size measurement of simulated colorectal polyps when using: VSE, ER, and forceps. Six endoscopists performed 60 measurements randomized at a 1:1:1 ratio using each method. Primary outcome was relative accuracy in polyp size measurement. Secondary outcomes included misclassification of sizes at the 5, 10, and 20mm thresholds. RESULT(S): A total of 360 measurements were performed. The relative accuracy of biopsy forceps, ER, and VSE was 78.9% (95%CI=76.2-81.5), 78.4% (95%CI=76.0-80.8), and 82.7% (95%CI=80.8-84.8). VSE had significantly higher accuracy compared to biopsy forceps (p=0.02) and ER (p=0.006). VSE misclassified a lower percentage of polyps >5mm as ≤5mm (9.4%) compared to forceps (15.7%) and ER (20.9%). VSE misclassified a lower percentage of ≥20mm polyps as <20mm (8.3%) compared with forceps (66.7%) and ER (75.0%). 25.6%, 25.5%, and 22.5% of polyps ≥10mm were misclassified as <10mm with ER, forceps, and VSE, respectively. CONCLUSION(S): VSE had significantly higher relative accuracy in measuring polyps compared to ER or forceps assisted measurement. VSE improves correct classification of polyps at clinically important size thresholds. PLEASE ACKNOWLEDGE ALL FUNDING AGENCIES BY CHECKING THE APPLICABLE BOXES BELOW: None DISCLOSURE OF INTEREST: R. Djinbachian: None Declared, M. Taghiakbari: None Declared, C. Haumesser: None Declared, M. Zarandi-Nowroozi: None Declared, M. Abou-Khalil: None Declared, S. Sidani: None Declared, J. Liu: None Declared, B. Panzini: None Declared, D. von Renteln Grant / Research support from: Daniel von Renteln is supported by a “Fonds de Recherche du Québec Santé” (FRQS) career development award and has received research funding from ERBE, Ventage, Pendopharm, Fujifilm, and Pentax., Consultant of: Boston Scientific and Pendopharm, |
format | Online Article Text |
id | pubmed-9991382 |
institution | National Center for Biotechnology Information |
language | English |
publishDate | 2023 |
publisher | Oxford University Press |
record_format | MEDLINE/PubMed |
spelling | pubmed-99913822023-03-08 A123 COMPARING SIZE MEASUREMENT OF SIMULATED COLORECTAL POLYPS WHEN USING A NOVEL VIRTUAL SCALE ENDOSCOPE, ENDOSCOPIC RULER OR FORCEPS: A BLINDED RANDOMIZED TRIAL Djinbachian, R Taghiakbari, M Haumesser, C Zarandi-Nowroozi, M Abou-Khalil, M Sidani, S Liu, J Panzini, B von Renteln, D J Can Assoc Gastroenterol Poster Presentations BACKGROUND: Accurate polyp size measurement is important for guideline conforming choice of polypectomy techniques and subsequent surveillance interval assignments. Some endoscopic tools (forceps or endoscopic rulers [ER]) exist to help with visual size estimation. A virtual scale endoscope (VSE) has been developed that allows superimposing a virtual measurement scale during live endoscopies. PURPOSE: Our aim was to evaluate the performance of VSE when compared to ER and forceps-based measurement. METHOD: We conducted a randomized trial to evaluate the relative accuracy of size measurement of simulated colorectal polyps when using: VSE, ER, and forceps. Six endoscopists performed 60 measurements randomized at a 1:1:1 ratio using each method. Primary outcome was relative accuracy in polyp size measurement. Secondary outcomes included misclassification of sizes at the 5, 10, and 20mm thresholds. RESULT(S): A total of 360 measurements were performed. The relative accuracy of biopsy forceps, ER, and VSE was 78.9% (95%CI=76.2-81.5), 78.4% (95%CI=76.0-80.8), and 82.7% (95%CI=80.8-84.8). VSE had significantly higher accuracy compared to biopsy forceps (p=0.02) and ER (p=0.006). VSE misclassified a lower percentage of polyps >5mm as ≤5mm (9.4%) compared to forceps (15.7%) and ER (20.9%). VSE misclassified a lower percentage of ≥20mm polyps as <20mm (8.3%) compared with forceps (66.7%) and ER (75.0%). 25.6%, 25.5%, and 22.5% of polyps ≥10mm were misclassified as <10mm with ER, forceps, and VSE, respectively. CONCLUSION(S): VSE had significantly higher relative accuracy in measuring polyps compared to ER or forceps assisted measurement. VSE improves correct classification of polyps at clinically important size thresholds. PLEASE ACKNOWLEDGE ALL FUNDING AGENCIES BY CHECKING THE APPLICABLE BOXES BELOW: None DISCLOSURE OF INTEREST: R. Djinbachian: None Declared, M. Taghiakbari: None Declared, C. Haumesser: None Declared, M. Zarandi-Nowroozi: None Declared, M. Abou-Khalil: None Declared, S. Sidani: None Declared, J. Liu: None Declared, B. Panzini: None Declared, D. von Renteln Grant / Research support from: Daniel von Renteln is supported by a “Fonds de Recherche du Québec Santé” (FRQS) career development award and has received research funding from ERBE, Ventage, Pendopharm, Fujifilm, and Pentax., Consultant of: Boston Scientific and Pendopharm, Oxford University Press 2023-03-07 /pmc/articles/PMC9991382/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/jcag/gwac036.123 Text en ڣ The Author(s) 2023. Published by Oxford University Press on behalf of the Canadian Association of Gastroenterology. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted reuse, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original work is properly cited. |
spellingShingle | Poster Presentations Djinbachian, R Taghiakbari, M Haumesser, C Zarandi-Nowroozi, M Abou-Khalil, M Sidani, S Liu, J Panzini, B von Renteln, D A123 COMPARING SIZE MEASUREMENT OF SIMULATED COLORECTAL POLYPS WHEN USING A NOVEL VIRTUAL SCALE ENDOSCOPE, ENDOSCOPIC RULER OR FORCEPS: A BLINDED RANDOMIZED TRIAL |
title | A123 COMPARING SIZE MEASUREMENT OF SIMULATED COLORECTAL POLYPS WHEN USING A NOVEL VIRTUAL SCALE ENDOSCOPE, ENDOSCOPIC RULER OR FORCEPS: A BLINDED RANDOMIZED TRIAL |
title_full | A123 COMPARING SIZE MEASUREMENT OF SIMULATED COLORECTAL POLYPS WHEN USING A NOVEL VIRTUAL SCALE ENDOSCOPE, ENDOSCOPIC RULER OR FORCEPS: A BLINDED RANDOMIZED TRIAL |
title_fullStr | A123 COMPARING SIZE MEASUREMENT OF SIMULATED COLORECTAL POLYPS WHEN USING A NOVEL VIRTUAL SCALE ENDOSCOPE, ENDOSCOPIC RULER OR FORCEPS: A BLINDED RANDOMIZED TRIAL |
title_full_unstemmed | A123 COMPARING SIZE MEASUREMENT OF SIMULATED COLORECTAL POLYPS WHEN USING A NOVEL VIRTUAL SCALE ENDOSCOPE, ENDOSCOPIC RULER OR FORCEPS: A BLINDED RANDOMIZED TRIAL |
title_short | A123 COMPARING SIZE MEASUREMENT OF SIMULATED COLORECTAL POLYPS WHEN USING A NOVEL VIRTUAL SCALE ENDOSCOPE, ENDOSCOPIC RULER OR FORCEPS: A BLINDED RANDOMIZED TRIAL |
title_sort | a123 comparing size measurement of simulated colorectal polyps when using a novel virtual scale endoscope, endoscopic ruler or forceps: a blinded randomized trial |
topic | Poster Presentations |
url | https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9991382/ http://dx.doi.org/10.1093/jcag/gwac036.123 |
work_keys_str_mv | AT djinbachianr a123comparingsizemeasurementofsimulatedcolorectalpolypswhenusinganovelvirtualscaleendoscopeendoscopicrulerorforcepsablindedrandomizedtrial AT taghiakbarim a123comparingsizemeasurementofsimulatedcolorectalpolypswhenusinganovelvirtualscaleendoscopeendoscopicrulerorforcepsablindedrandomizedtrial AT haumesserc a123comparingsizemeasurementofsimulatedcolorectalpolypswhenusinganovelvirtualscaleendoscopeendoscopicrulerorforcepsablindedrandomizedtrial AT zarandinowroozim a123comparingsizemeasurementofsimulatedcolorectalpolypswhenusinganovelvirtualscaleendoscopeendoscopicrulerorforcepsablindedrandomizedtrial AT aboukhalilm a123comparingsizemeasurementofsimulatedcolorectalpolypswhenusinganovelvirtualscaleendoscopeendoscopicrulerorforcepsablindedrandomizedtrial AT sidanis a123comparingsizemeasurementofsimulatedcolorectalpolypswhenusinganovelvirtualscaleendoscopeendoscopicrulerorforcepsablindedrandomizedtrial AT liuj a123comparingsizemeasurementofsimulatedcolorectalpolypswhenusinganovelvirtualscaleendoscopeendoscopicrulerorforcepsablindedrandomizedtrial AT panzinib a123comparingsizemeasurementofsimulatedcolorectalpolypswhenusinganovelvirtualscaleendoscopeendoscopicrulerorforcepsablindedrandomizedtrial AT vonrentelnd a123comparingsizemeasurementofsimulatedcolorectalpolypswhenusinganovelvirtualscaleendoscopeendoscopicrulerorforcepsablindedrandomizedtrial |