Cargando…

Community defense against organized crime in Mexico: Governmentality and co-production of security

The article analyzes different experiences of organized community defense groups in Guerrero and Michoacán, facing the insecurity generated by drug trafficking through the diversification of their lucrative activities. It emphasizes that the participation of communities in the appropriation of their...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Fuentes Díaz, Antonio, Fini, Daniele
Formato: Online Artículo
Lenguaje:spa
Publicado: Instituto de Investigaciones Histórico-Sociales 2022
Acceso en línea:https://clivajes.uv.mx/index.php/Clivajes/article/view/2721
_version_ 1780756336925999104
author Fuentes Díaz, Antonio
Fini, Daniele
author_facet Fuentes Díaz, Antonio
Fini, Daniele
author_sort Fuentes Díaz, Antonio
collection Clivajes, Revista de Ciencias Sociales
description The article analyzes different experiences of organized community defense groups in Guerrero and Michoacán, facing the insecurity generated by drug trafficking through the diversification of their lucrative activities. It emphasizes that the participation of communities in the appropriation of their security takes place in a social environment in which legality and illegality are confused, a functional ambiguous zone in the context of regional economic reconfigurations that favored violence. The article discusses the heterogeneity of the defensive armed groups in this region, emphasizing the tense tolerance of the State towards their manifestation, trying to submit them to the citizen participation model of security. It also discusses the relevance and limits of the categories with which they have been attempted to characterize the groups that organize themselves to guarantee security and order in environments affected by violence that has been centered on the self-defense/community police dichotomy, proposing the notion of “community defense” to encompass both phenomena. Keywords: Community defense, Insecurity, Organized crime, Violence, Co-production of security
format Online
Article
id oai_https_--clivajes-article-2721
institution Universidad Veracruzana
language spa
publishDate 2022
publisher Instituto de Investigaciones Histórico-Sociales
record_format ojs
spelling oai_https_--clivajes-article-27212022-10-25T01:13:51Z Community defense against organized crime in Mexico: Governmentality and co-production of security Defensa comunitaria frente a la criminalidad organizada en México: Gubernamentalidad y coproduccion de la seguridad Défense communautaire face à la criminalité organisée au Mexique : Gouvernementalité et coproduction de la sécurité Fuentes Díaz, Antonio Fini, Daniele The article analyzes different experiences of organized community defense groups in Guerrero and Michoacán, facing the insecurity generated by drug trafficking through the diversification of their lucrative activities. It emphasizes that the participation of communities in the appropriation of their security takes place in a social environment in which legality and illegality are confused, a functional ambiguous zone in the context of regional economic reconfigurations that favored violence. The article discusses the heterogeneity of the defensive armed groups in this region, emphasizing the tense tolerance of the State towards their manifestation, trying to submit them to the citizen participation model of security. It also discusses the relevance and limits of the categories with which they have been attempted to characterize the groups that organize themselves to guarantee security and order in environments affected by violence that has been centered on the self-defense/community police dichotomy, proposing the notion of “community defense” to encompass both phenomena. Keywords: Community defense, Insecurity, Organized crime, Violence, Co-production of security El artículo analiza diferentes experiencias de grupos organizados para la defensa comunitaria en Guerrero y Michoacán, frente a la inseguridad que genera el narcotráfico a través de la diversificación de sus actividades lucrativas. Destaca que la participación de las comunidades en la apropiación de su seguridad se da en un entorno social en el que se confunden legalidad e ilegalidad, una zona ambigua funcional en el contexto de reconfiguraciones económicas regionales que favorecieron la violencia. El artículo discute la heterogeneidad de los grupos armados defensivos en esa región, acentuando la tensa tolerancia del Estado hacia su manifestación, tratando de someterlos al modelo de participación ciudadana de la seguridad. También discute la relevancia y el límite de las categorías con las que se ha intentado caracterizar a los grupos que se organizan para garantizar la seguridad y el orden en entornos afectados por la violencia que ha sido centrada en la dicotomía autodefensas/policías comunitarias, proponiendo la noción “defensa comunitaria” para abarcar ambos fenómenos. Palabras clave: Defensa comunitaria, Inseguridad, Crimen organizado, Violencia, Coproducción de la seguridad L’article analyse différentes expériences de groupes organisés pour la défense communautaire à l’État de Guerrero et à l’État de Michoacán au Mexique, face à l’insécurité qui génère le trafic de stupéfiants à travers la diversification de leurs activités lucratives. On met l’accent sur la participation des communautés dans l’appropriation de leur sécurité qui se passe dans un entourage social où la légalité et l’illégalité se mêlent, et sur une zone ambiguë fonctionnelle dans le contexte de reconfigurations économiques régionales qui ont favorisé la violence. L’article discute l’hétérogénéité des groupes armés défensifs dans cette région, en mettant l’accent sur la tolérance tendue de l’État envers leur manifestation, en essayant de les soumettre au modèle de participation de la citoyenneté dans la sécurité.  On discute aussi la pertinence et la limite des catégories avec lesquelles on a essayé de caractériser les groupes qui s’organisent pour garantir la sécurité et l’ordre en entourages endommagés par la violence qui a été centrée dans la dichotomie autodéfense/agents de police communautaires, en proposant la notion « défense communautaire » pour inclure tous les deux phénomènes. Mots clés : Défense communautaire, Insécurité, Crime organisé, Violence, Coproduction de la sécurité Instituto de Investigaciones Histórico-Sociales 2022-10-25 info:eu-repo/semantics/article info:eu-repo/semantics/publishedVersion application/pdf https://clivajes.uv.mx/index.php/Clivajes/article/view/2721 Clivajes. Revista de Ciencias Sociales; Núm. 16 (2021): Derechos humanos, diversidad y población 2395-9495 spa https://clivajes.uv.mx/index.php/Clivajes/article/view/2721/4514 Derechos de autor 2022 Antonio Fuentes Díaz, Daniele Fini
spellingShingle Fuentes Díaz, Antonio
Fini, Daniele
Community defense against organized crime in Mexico: Governmentality and co-production of security
title Community defense against organized crime in Mexico: Governmentality and co-production of security
title_alt Defensa comunitaria frente a la criminalidad organizada en México: Gubernamentalidad y coproduccion de la seguridad
Défense communautaire face à la criminalité organisée au Mexique : Gouvernementalité et coproduction de la sécurité
title_full Community defense against organized crime in Mexico: Governmentality and co-production of security
title_fullStr Community defense against organized crime in Mexico: Governmentality and co-production of security
title_full_unstemmed Community defense against organized crime in Mexico: Governmentality and co-production of security
title_short Community defense against organized crime in Mexico: Governmentality and co-production of security
title_sort community defense against organized crime in mexico: governmentality and co-production of security
url https://clivajes.uv.mx/index.php/Clivajes/article/view/2721
work_keys_str_mv AT fuentesdiazantonio communitydefenseagainstorganizedcrimeinmexicogovernmentalityandcoproductionofsecurity
AT finidaniele communitydefenseagainstorganizedcrimeinmexicogovernmentalityandcoproductionofsecurity
AT fuentesdiazantonio defensacomunitariafrentealacriminalidadorganizadaenmexicogubernamentalidadycoproducciondelaseguridad
AT finidaniele defensacomunitariafrentealacriminalidadorganizadaenmexicogubernamentalidadycoproducciondelaseguridad
AT fuentesdiazantonio defensecommunautairefacealacriminaliteorganiseeaumexiquegouvernementaliteetcoproductiondelasecurite
AT finidaniele defensecommunautairefacealacriminaliteorganiseeaumexiquegouvernementaliteetcoproductiondelasecurite