Dengue virus serotypic replacement of NS3 protease or helicase domain causes chimeric viral attenuation but can be recovered by a compensated mutation at helicase domain or NS2B, respectively

Mosquito-borne dengue viruses (DENVs) have evolved to four serotypes with 69%–78% amino acid identities, resulting in incomplete immunity, where one serotype’s infection does not cross-protect against secondary infections by other serotypes. Despite the amino acid differences, structural and nonstructural (NS) proteins among serotypes play similar functions. NS3 is an enzyme complex: NS3 has N-terminal protease (PRO) and C-terminal helicase (HEL) activities in addition to 5’ RNA triphosphatase (5’RTP), which is involved in the RNA capping process. In this study, the effects of NS3 replacements among serotypes were tested. The replacement of NS3 full-length (FULL), PRO or HEL region suppressed viral replication in BHK-21 mammalian cells, while the single compensatory mutation improved the viral replications; P364S mutation in HEL revived PRO (DENV3)-replaced DENV1, while S68T alteration in NS2B recovered HEL (DENV1)-replaced DENV2. The results suggest that the interactions between PRO and HEL as well as HEL and NS2B are required for replication competence. Lower-frequency mutations also appeared at various locations in viral proteins, although after infecting C6/36 mosquito cells, the mutations’ frequencies changed, and/or new mutations appeared. In contrast, the inter-domain region (INT, 12 amino acids)-replaced chimera quickly replicated without mutation in BHK-21 cells, although extended cell culture accumulated various mutations. These results suggest that NS3 variously interacts with DENV proteins, in which the chimeric NS3 domain replacements induced amino acid mutations, irrespective of replication efficiency. However, the viral sequences are further adjusted for replication efficiency, to fit in both mammalian cells and mosquito cells. IMPORTANCE: Enzyme activities for replicating DENV 5’ cap positive (+) sense RNA have been shown to reside in NS3 and NS5. However, it remains unknown how these enzymes coordinately synthesize negative (-) sense RNA, from which abundant 5’ cap (+) sense RNA is produced. We previously revealed that NS5 dimerization and NS5 methyltransferase(MT)–NS3HEL interaction are important for DENV replication. Here, we found that replication incompetence due to NS3PRO or HEL replacement was compensated by a mutation at HEL or NS2B, respectively, suggesting that the interactions among NS2B, NS3PRO, and HEL are critical for DENV replication.