Cargando…

The intensity of a resistance exercise session can be quantified by the work rate of exercise

PURPOSE: Athletes regularly perform resistance training, yet it is unknown how best to monitor its intensity. This study compared different resistance exercise intensity metrics to determine their sensitivity to manipulating work rate (via altering inter-set rest and load). METHODS: Following baseli...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Scott, Brendan R., Marston, Kieran J., Teo, Shaun Y. M., Forrest, Mitchell R. L., Jonson, Andrew, Walden, Thomas P., Galna, Brook, Peiffer, Jeremiah J.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Public Library of Science 2023
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10553797/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37797065
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0291857
_version_ 1785116259093839872
author Scott, Brendan R.
Marston, Kieran J.
Teo, Shaun Y. M.
Forrest, Mitchell R. L.
Jonson, Andrew
Walden, Thomas P.
Galna, Brook
Peiffer, Jeremiah J.
author_facet Scott, Brendan R.
Marston, Kieran J.
Teo, Shaun Y. M.
Forrest, Mitchell R. L.
Jonson, Andrew
Walden, Thomas P.
Galna, Brook
Peiffer, Jeremiah J.
author_sort Scott, Brendan R.
collection PubMed
description PURPOSE: Athletes regularly perform resistance training, yet it is unknown how best to monitor its intensity. This study compared different resistance exercise intensity metrics to determine their sensitivity to manipulating work rate (via altering inter-set rest and load). METHODS: Following baseline testing for 10- and 3-repetition maximum (RM; squat and bench press), fourteen trained participants completed four volume-matched protocols in a randomised order: 3x10 with 85% 10RM, 60 s rest (3x10(60s)); 3x10 with 85% 10RM, 180 s (3x10(180s)); 8x3 with 85% 3RM, 120 s (8x3(120s)); 8x3 with 85% 3RM, 300 s (8x3(300s)). Internal intensity was quantified via rate of oxygen consumption ([Image: see text] ), heart rate, blood lactate concentration, and rating of perceived exertion (RPE). External intensity was assessed via previously developed “Training-Intensity” (TI) and “Intensity-Index” (II) metrics, and from exercise work rate (expressed as kg∙min(-1) and joules∙min(-1)). RESULTS: Internal intensity and work-rate metrics were highest for 3x10(60s), followed by 3x10(180s), 8x3(120s) and 8x3(300s) (p≤0.027). TI and II were higher for 8x3 than 3x10 protocols (p<0.001), but not different within these configurations. Internal intensity measures were more strongly correlated with work rate (r = 0.37–0.96) than TI and II (r = -0.42–0.33) metrics. CONCLUSIONS: Work rate corroborated objective internal intensity metrics during resistance exercise, with the highest work rate session (3x10(60s)) also eliciting greater RPE scores than other protocols. In contrast, the TI and II did not agree with other intensity measures, likely because they do not consider rest periods. Practitioners can plan for the physiological and perceptual demands of resistance training by estimating work rate.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-10553797
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2023
publisher Public Library of Science
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-105537972023-10-06 The intensity of a resistance exercise session can be quantified by the work rate of exercise Scott, Brendan R. Marston, Kieran J. Teo, Shaun Y. M. Forrest, Mitchell R. L. Jonson, Andrew Walden, Thomas P. Galna, Brook Peiffer, Jeremiah J. PLoS One Research Article PURPOSE: Athletes regularly perform resistance training, yet it is unknown how best to monitor its intensity. This study compared different resistance exercise intensity metrics to determine their sensitivity to manipulating work rate (via altering inter-set rest and load). METHODS: Following baseline testing for 10- and 3-repetition maximum (RM; squat and bench press), fourteen trained participants completed four volume-matched protocols in a randomised order: 3x10 with 85% 10RM, 60 s rest (3x10(60s)); 3x10 with 85% 10RM, 180 s (3x10(180s)); 8x3 with 85% 3RM, 120 s (8x3(120s)); 8x3 with 85% 3RM, 300 s (8x3(300s)). Internal intensity was quantified via rate of oxygen consumption ([Image: see text] ), heart rate, blood lactate concentration, and rating of perceived exertion (RPE). External intensity was assessed via previously developed “Training-Intensity” (TI) and “Intensity-Index” (II) metrics, and from exercise work rate (expressed as kg∙min(-1) and joules∙min(-1)). RESULTS: Internal intensity and work-rate metrics were highest for 3x10(60s), followed by 3x10(180s), 8x3(120s) and 8x3(300s) (p≤0.027). TI and II were higher for 8x3 than 3x10 protocols (p<0.001), but not different within these configurations. Internal intensity measures were more strongly correlated with work rate (r = 0.37–0.96) than TI and II (r = -0.42–0.33) metrics. CONCLUSIONS: Work rate corroborated objective internal intensity metrics during resistance exercise, with the highest work rate session (3x10(60s)) also eliciting greater RPE scores than other protocols. In contrast, the TI and II did not agree with other intensity measures, likely because they do not consider rest periods. Practitioners can plan for the physiological and perceptual demands of resistance training by estimating work rate. Public Library of Science 2023-10-05 /pmc/articles/PMC10553797/ /pubmed/37797065 http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0291857 Text en © 2023 Scott et al https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/) , which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
spellingShingle Research Article
Scott, Brendan R.
Marston, Kieran J.
Teo, Shaun Y. M.
Forrest, Mitchell R. L.
Jonson, Andrew
Walden, Thomas P.
Galna, Brook
Peiffer, Jeremiah J.
The intensity of a resistance exercise session can be quantified by the work rate of exercise
title The intensity of a resistance exercise session can be quantified by the work rate of exercise
title_full The intensity of a resistance exercise session can be quantified by the work rate of exercise
title_fullStr The intensity of a resistance exercise session can be quantified by the work rate of exercise
title_full_unstemmed The intensity of a resistance exercise session can be quantified by the work rate of exercise
title_short The intensity of a resistance exercise session can be quantified by the work rate of exercise
title_sort intensity of a resistance exercise session can be quantified by the work rate of exercise
topic Research Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC10553797/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/37797065
http://dx.doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0291857
work_keys_str_mv AT scottbrendanr theintensityofaresistanceexercisesessioncanbequantifiedbytheworkrateofexercise
AT marstonkieranj theintensityofaresistanceexercisesessioncanbequantifiedbytheworkrateofexercise
AT teoshaunym theintensityofaresistanceexercisesessioncanbequantifiedbytheworkrateofexercise
AT forrestmitchellrl theintensityofaresistanceexercisesessioncanbequantifiedbytheworkrateofexercise
AT jonsonandrew theintensityofaresistanceexercisesessioncanbequantifiedbytheworkrateofexercise
AT waldenthomasp theintensityofaresistanceexercisesessioncanbequantifiedbytheworkrateofexercise
AT galnabrook theintensityofaresistanceexercisesessioncanbequantifiedbytheworkrateofexercise
AT peifferjeremiahj theintensityofaresistanceexercisesessioncanbequantifiedbytheworkrateofexercise
AT scottbrendanr intensityofaresistanceexercisesessioncanbequantifiedbytheworkrateofexercise
AT marstonkieranj intensityofaresistanceexercisesessioncanbequantifiedbytheworkrateofexercise
AT teoshaunym intensityofaresistanceexercisesessioncanbequantifiedbytheworkrateofexercise
AT forrestmitchellrl intensityofaresistanceexercisesessioncanbequantifiedbytheworkrateofexercise
AT jonsonandrew intensityofaresistanceexercisesessioncanbequantifiedbytheworkrateofexercise
AT waldenthomasp intensityofaresistanceexercisesessioncanbequantifiedbytheworkrateofexercise
AT galnabrook intensityofaresistanceexercisesessioncanbequantifiedbytheworkrateofexercise
AT peifferjeremiahj intensityofaresistanceexercisesessioncanbequantifiedbytheworkrateofexercise