Why Is there a Limit to the Changes in Myofilament Ca(2+)-Sensitivity Associated with Myopathy Causing Mutations?

Mutations in striated muscle contractile proteins have been found to be the cause of a number of inherited muscle diseases; in most cases the mechanism proposed for causing the disease is derangement of the thin filament-based Ca(2+)-regulatory system of the muscle. When considering the results of experiments reported over the last 15 years, one feature has been frequently noted, but rarely discussed: the magnitude of changes in myofilament Ca(2+)-sensitivity due to myopathy-causing mutations in skeletal or heart muscle seems to be always in the range 1.5–3x EC(50). Such consistency suggests it may be related to a fundamental property of muscle regulation; in this article we will investigate whether this observation is true and consider why this should be so. A literature search found 71 independent measurements of HCM mutation-induced change of EC(50) ranging from 1.15 to 3.8-fold with a mean of 1.87 ± 0.07 (sem). We also found 11 independent measurements of increased Ca(2+)-sensitivity due to mutations in skeletal muscle proteins ranging from 1.19 to 2.7-fold with a mean of 2.00 ± 0.16. Investigation of dilated cardiomyopathy-related mutations found 42 independent determinations with a range of EC(50) wt/mutant from 0.3 to 2.3. In addition we found 14 measurements of Ca(2+)-sensitivity changes due skeletal muscle myopathy mutations ranging from 0.39 to 0.63. Thus, our extensive literature search, although not necessarily complete, found that, indeed, the changes in myofilament Ca(2+)-sensitivity due to disease-causing mutations have a bimodal distribution and that the overall changes in Ca(2+)-sensitivity are quite small and do not extend beyond a three-fold increase or decrease in Ca(2+)-sensitivity. We discuss two mechanism that are not necessarily mutually exclusive. Firstly, it could be that the limit is set by the capabilities of the excitation-contraction machinery that supplies activating Ca(2+) and that striated muscle cannot work in a way compatible with life outside these limits; or it may be due to a fundamental property of the troponin system and the permitted conformational transitions compatible with efficient regulation.