The Chromatin Structure of CRISPR-Cas9 Target DNA Controls the Balance between Mutagenic and Homology-Directed Gene-Editing Events

Gene editing based on homology-directed repair (HDR) depends on donor DNA templates and programmable nucleases, e.g., RNA-guided CRISPR-Cas9 nucleases. However, next to inducing HDR involving the mending of chromosomal double-stranded breaks (DSBs) with donor DNA substrates, programmable nucleases also yield gene disruptions, triggered by competing non-homologous end joining (NHEJ) pathways. It is, therefore, imperative to identify parameters underlying the relationship between these two outcomes in the context of HDR-based gene editing. Here we implemented quantitative cellular systems, based on epigenetically regulated isogenic target sequences and donor DNA of viral, non-viral, and synthetic origins, to investigate gene-editing outcomes resulting from the interaction between different chromatin conformations and donor DNA structures. We report that, despite a significantly higher prevalence of NHEJ-derived events at euchromatin over Krüppel-associated box (KRAB)-impinged heterochromatin, HDR frequencies are instead generally less impacted by these alternative chromatin conformations. Hence, HDR increases in relation to NHEJ when open euchromatic target sequences acquire a closed heterochromatic state, with donor DNA structures determining, to some extent, the degree of this relative increase in HDR events at heterochromatin. Finally, restricting nuclease activity to HDR-permissive G2 and S phases of the cell cycle through a Cas9-Geminin construct yields lower, hence more favorable, NHEJ to HDR ratios, independently of the chromatin structure.