Cargando…

A Curriculum for Clerkship Students to Foster Professionalism Through Reflective Practice and Identity Formation

INTRODUCTION: Research suggests that students become less patient-centered and empathetic in response to both internal and external factors, including the organizational culture, or hidden curriculum, of medical school. Students often feel compelled to make compromises when they experience tension b...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Glod, Susan A., Richard, David, Gordon, Patricia, Fecile, Mary Lynn, Kees-Folts, Deborah, Kreher, Margaret, Moser, Eileen M., Wolpaw, Daniel R., Yang, Chengwu, Haidet, Paul
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Association of American Medical Colleges 2016
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6464454/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31008196
http://dx.doi.org/10.15766/mep_2374-8265.10416
_version_ 1783410863898624000
author Glod, Susan A.
Richard, David
Gordon, Patricia
Fecile, Mary Lynn
Kees-Folts, Deborah
Kreher, Margaret
Moser, Eileen M.
Wolpaw, Daniel R.
Yang, Chengwu
Haidet, Paul
author_facet Glod, Susan A.
Richard, David
Gordon, Patricia
Fecile, Mary Lynn
Kees-Folts, Deborah
Kreher, Margaret
Moser, Eileen M.
Wolpaw, Daniel R.
Yang, Chengwu
Haidet, Paul
author_sort Glod, Susan A.
collection PubMed
description INTRODUCTION: Research suggests that students become less patient-centered and empathetic in response to both internal and external factors, including the organizational culture, or hidden curriculum, of medical school. Students often feel compelled to make compromises when they experience tension between competing values in clinical teaching environments. To address this, we implemented a modular, longitudinal professionalism curriculum for third-year medical students, based on a conceptual model that highlights a student's ideal, as well as the internal and environmental forces that can either sustain or change their ideal over time. METHODS: As students progressed through the third year, they participated in various modules linked to different clerkships, each focusing on a different aspect of the conceptual model. Each module includes a reflective writing exercise followed by a faculty-facilitated discussion. RESULTS: In general, students rated the group discussions and faculty facilitation as the most useful parts of each session and the writing exercises as the least useful. Written comments were mostly favorable and suggested that the session facilitated self-reflection and provided a safe environment for students to discuss stressors of third-year clerkships. DISCUSSION: This curriculum represents a unique approach to fostering professional role formation through its broad potential applicability to multiple types and levels of learners, its adaptability to fit various course lengths and learning environments, and its incorporation of a conceptual model that allows individual learners to address different facets of the sustaining and acculturating forces that impact their personal professional identity formation for future encounters.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-6464454
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2016
publisher Association of American Medical Colleges
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-64644542019-04-19 A Curriculum for Clerkship Students to Foster Professionalism Through Reflective Practice and Identity Formation Glod, Susan A. Richard, David Gordon, Patricia Fecile, Mary Lynn Kees-Folts, Deborah Kreher, Margaret Moser, Eileen M. Wolpaw, Daniel R. Yang, Chengwu Haidet, Paul MedEdPORTAL Original Publication INTRODUCTION: Research suggests that students become less patient-centered and empathetic in response to both internal and external factors, including the organizational culture, or hidden curriculum, of medical school. Students often feel compelled to make compromises when they experience tension between competing values in clinical teaching environments. To address this, we implemented a modular, longitudinal professionalism curriculum for third-year medical students, based on a conceptual model that highlights a student's ideal, as well as the internal and environmental forces that can either sustain or change their ideal over time. METHODS: As students progressed through the third year, they participated in various modules linked to different clerkships, each focusing on a different aspect of the conceptual model. Each module includes a reflective writing exercise followed by a faculty-facilitated discussion. RESULTS: In general, students rated the group discussions and faculty facilitation as the most useful parts of each session and the writing exercises as the least useful. Written comments were mostly favorable and suggested that the session facilitated self-reflection and provided a safe environment for students to discuss stressors of third-year clerkships. DISCUSSION: This curriculum represents a unique approach to fostering professional role formation through its broad potential applicability to multiple types and levels of learners, its adaptability to fit various course lengths and learning environments, and its incorporation of a conceptual model that allows individual learners to address different facets of the sustaining and acculturating forces that impact their personal professional identity formation for future encounters. Association of American Medical Colleges 2016-06-17 /pmc/articles/PMC6464454/ /pubmed/31008196 http://dx.doi.org/10.15766/mep_2374-8265.10416 Text en Copyright © 2016 Glod et al. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode This is an open-access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/legalcode) license.
spellingShingle Original Publication
Glod, Susan A.
Richard, David
Gordon, Patricia
Fecile, Mary Lynn
Kees-Folts, Deborah
Kreher, Margaret
Moser, Eileen M.
Wolpaw, Daniel R.
Yang, Chengwu
Haidet, Paul
A Curriculum for Clerkship Students to Foster Professionalism Through Reflective Practice and Identity Formation
title A Curriculum for Clerkship Students to Foster Professionalism Through Reflective Practice and Identity Formation
title_full A Curriculum for Clerkship Students to Foster Professionalism Through Reflective Practice and Identity Formation
title_fullStr A Curriculum for Clerkship Students to Foster Professionalism Through Reflective Practice and Identity Formation
title_full_unstemmed A Curriculum for Clerkship Students to Foster Professionalism Through Reflective Practice and Identity Formation
title_short A Curriculum for Clerkship Students to Foster Professionalism Through Reflective Practice and Identity Formation
title_sort curriculum for clerkship students to foster professionalism through reflective practice and identity formation
topic Original Publication
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC6464454/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/31008196
http://dx.doi.org/10.15766/mep_2374-8265.10416
work_keys_str_mv AT glodsusana acurriculumforclerkshipstudentstofosterprofessionalismthroughreflectivepracticeandidentityformation
AT richarddavid acurriculumforclerkshipstudentstofosterprofessionalismthroughreflectivepracticeandidentityformation
AT gordonpatricia acurriculumforclerkshipstudentstofosterprofessionalismthroughreflectivepracticeandidentityformation
AT fecilemarylynn acurriculumforclerkshipstudentstofosterprofessionalismthroughreflectivepracticeandidentityformation
AT keesfoltsdeborah acurriculumforclerkshipstudentstofosterprofessionalismthroughreflectivepracticeandidentityformation
AT krehermargaret acurriculumforclerkshipstudentstofosterprofessionalismthroughreflectivepracticeandidentityformation
AT mosereileenm acurriculumforclerkshipstudentstofosterprofessionalismthroughreflectivepracticeandidentityformation
AT wolpawdanielr acurriculumforclerkshipstudentstofosterprofessionalismthroughreflectivepracticeandidentityformation
AT yangchengwu acurriculumforclerkshipstudentstofosterprofessionalismthroughreflectivepracticeandidentityformation
AT haidetpaul acurriculumforclerkshipstudentstofosterprofessionalismthroughreflectivepracticeandidentityformation
AT glodsusana curriculumforclerkshipstudentstofosterprofessionalismthroughreflectivepracticeandidentityformation
AT richarddavid curriculumforclerkshipstudentstofosterprofessionalismthroughreflectivepracticeandidentityformation
AT gordonpatricia curriculumforclerkshipstudentstofosterprofessionalismthroughreflectivepracticeandidentityformation
AT fecilemarylynn curriculumforclerkshipstudentstofosterprofessionalismthroughreflectivepracticeandidentityformation
AT keesfoltsdeborah curriculumforclerkshipstudentstofosterprofessionalismthroughreflectivepracticeandidentityformation
AT krehermargaret curriculumforclerkshipstudentstofosterprofessionalismthroughreflectivepracticeandidentityformation
AT mosereileenm curriculumforclerkshipstudentstofosterprofessionalismthroughreflectivepracticeandidentityformation
AT wolpawdanielr curriculumforclerkshipstudentstofosterprofessionalismthroughreflectivepracticeandidentityformation
AT yangchengwu curriculumforclerkshipstudentstofosterprofessionalismthroughreflectivepracticeandidentityformation
AT haidetpaul curriculumforclerkshipstudentstofosterprofessionalismthroughreflectivepracticeandidentityformation