The effect of phage genetic diversity on bacterial resistance evolution

CRISPR-Cas adaptive immune systems are found in bacteria and archaea and provide defence against phage by inserting phage-derived sequences into CRISPR loci on the host genome to provide sequence specific immunological memory against re-infection. Under laboratory conditions the bacterium Pseudomonas aeruginosa readily evolves the high levels of CRISPR-based immunity against clonal populations of its phage DMS3vir, which in turn causes rapid extinction of the phage. However, in nature phage populations are likely to be more genetically diverse, which could theoretically impact the frequency at which CRISPR-based immunity evolves which in turn can alter phage persistence over time. Here we experimentally test these ideas and found that a smaller proportion of infected bacterial populations evolved CRISPR-based immunity against more genetically diverse phage populations, with the majority of the population evolving a sm preventing phage adsorption and providing generalised defence against a broader range of phage genotypes. However, those cells that do evolve CRISPR-based immunity in response to infection with more genetically diverse phage acquire greater numbers of CRISPR memory sequences in order to resist a wider range of phage genotypes. Despite differences in bacterial resistance evolution, the rates of phage extinction were similar in the context of clonal and diverse phage infections suggesting selection for CRISPR-based immunity or sm-based resistance plays a relatively minor role in the ecological dynamics in this study. Collectively, these data help to understand the drivers of CRISPR-based immunity and their consequences for bacteria-phage coexistence, and, more broadly, when generalised defences will be favoured over more specific defences.