Cargando…

Identification of Possible Pre-Slaughter Indicators to Predict Stress and Meat Quality: A Study on Heavy Pigs

SIMPLE SUMMARY: This study aimed at identifying, on the basis of objective evaluations (blood parameters): (1) the pre-slaughter treatments that result in higher stress for heavy pigs and can therefore be used as pre-slaughter stress indicators; (2) the meat quality parameters that show the largest...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Sardi, Luca, Gastaldo, Alessandro, Borciani, Marzia, Bertolini, Andrea, Musi, Valeria, Martelli, Giovanna, Cavallini, Damiano, Rubini, Giulia, Nannoni, Eleonora
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: MDPI 2020
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7341522/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32486015
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ani10060945
_version_ 1783555258445725696
author Sardi, Luca
Gastaldo, Alessandro
Borciani, Marzia
Bertolini, Andrea
Musi, Valeria
Martelli, Giovanna
Cavallini, Damiano
Rubini, Giulia
Nannoni, Eleonora
author_facet Sardi, Luca
Gastaldo, Alessandro
Borciani, Marzia
Bertolini, Andrea
Musi, Valeria
Martelli, Giovanna
Cavallini, Damiano
Rubini, Giulia
Nannoni, Eleonora
author_sort Sardi, Luca
collection PubMed
description SIMPLE SUMMARY: This study aimed at identifying, on the basis of objective evaluations (blood parameters): (1) the pre-slaughter treatments that result in higher stress for heavy pigs and can therefore be used as pre-slaughter stress indicators; (2) the meat quality parameters that show the largest variation as a response to the stress experienced during pre-slaughter handling. Two blood parameters (cortisol and creatine kinase) were used to categorize pigs into two groups (clusters) depending on transport conditions: “higher stress” and “lower stress”. Our results indicate that the variables/indexes which differed more widely between the two clusters (namely, average vehicle speed during transport, welfare slaughter score, overall transport and slaughter welfare index (TSWI), distance travelled, group stability, and behaviors—slips, falls, and overlaps—during unloading) might be considered as the best descriptors of the welfare conditions experienced by Italian heavy pigs during pre-slaughter handling. However, we observed no consistent effects of the stress experienced during pre-slaughter handling on meat quality, which warrants the need for further studies addressing: (1) the individual stress response and meat quality variability in pigs within the same transport; (2) the relationships between the variables examined and meat quality, with the aim to improve the TSWI. ABSTRACT: This study aimed at identifying possible pre-slaughter indicators and/or indexes to be used to predict pig stress response and meat quality variation. Data were collected on 44 shipments (loads) of Italian heavy pigs. For each shipment, several pre-slaughter parameters were recorded on farm, during transport, and at the slaughterhouse. Blood and meat samples were taken from 10 pigs from every of the 44 loads included in the study (N = 440). Blood samples were used to assess cortisol and creatine kinase levels, whereas meat samples were used to assess meat quality (pH, instrumental color, tenderness, water-holding capacity, and sensory analysis). Cluster analysis of blood parameters allowed the categorization of the shipments into two main clusters: Lower Stress (LS) and Higher Stress (HS). The variables/indexes statistically differing between the two clusters were: average vehicle speed during transport, welfare index at slaughter (i.e., “slaughter score”), overall transport and slaughter welfare index (TSWI), distance travelled, and behaviors (slips, falls, overlaps) during unloading, which appeared to be the best descriptors of the welfare conditions experienced by Italian heavy pigs during pre-slaughter handling. No consistent effects of the stress level experienced on meat quality was detected, which warrants the need for further studies conducted under more variable pre-slaughter conditions, with the aim of simplifying and improving the TSWI.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-7341522
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2020
publisher MDPI
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-73415222020-07-14 Identification of Possible Pre-Slaughter Indicators to Predict Stress and Meat Quality: A Study on Heavy Pigs Sardi, Luca Gastaldo, Alessandro Borciani, Marzia Bertolini, Andrea Musi, Valeria Martelli, Giovanna Cavallini, Damiano Rubini, Giulia Nannoni, Eleonora Animals (Basel) Article SIMPLE SUMMARY: This study aimed at identifying, on the basis of objective evaluations (blood parameters): (1) the pre-slaughter treatments that result in higher stress for heavy pigs and can therefore be used as pre-slaughter stress indicators; (2) the meat quality parameters that show the largest variation as a response to the stress experienced during pre-slaughter handling. Two blood parameters (cortisol and creatine kinase) were used to categorize pigs into two groups (clusters) depending on transport conditions: “higher stress” and “lower stress”. Our results indicate that the variables/indexes which differed more widely between the two clusters (namely, average vehicle speed during transport, welfare slaughter score, overall transport and slaughter welfare index (TSWI), distance travelled, group stability, and behaviors—slips, falls, and overlaps—during unloading) might be considered as the best descriptors of the welfare conditions experienced by Italian heavy pigs during pre-slaughter handling. However, we observed no consistent effects of the stress experienced during pre-slaughter handling on meat quality, which warrants the need for further studies addressing: (1) the individual stress response and meat quality variability in pigs within the same transport; (2) the relationships between the variables examined and meat quality, with the aim to improve the TSWI. ABSTRACT: This study aimed at identifying possible pre-slaughter indicators and/or indexes to be used to predict pig stress response and meat quality variation. Data were collected on 44 shipments (loads) of Italian heavy pigs. For each shipment, several pre-slaughter parameters were recorded on farm, during transport, and at the slaughterhouse. Blood and meat samples were taken from 10 pigs from every of the 44 loads included in the study (N = 440). Blood samples were used to assess cortisol and creatine kinase levels, whereas meat samples were used to assess meat quality (pH, instrumental color, tenderness, water-holding capacity, and sensory analysis). Cluster analysis of blood parameters allowed the categorization of the shipments into two main clusters: Lower Stress (LS) and Higher Stress (HS). The variables/indexes statistically differing between the two clusters were: average vehicle speed during transport, welfare index at slaughter (i.e., “slaughter score”), overall transport and slaughter welfare index (TSWI), distance travelled, and behaviors (slips, falls, overlaps) during unloading, which appeared to be the best descriptors of the welfare conditions experienced by Italian heavy pigs during pre-slaughter handling. No consistent effects of the stress level experienced on meat quality was detected, which warrants the need for further studies conducted under more variable pre-slaughter conditions, with the aim of simplifying and improving the TSWI. MDPI 2020-05-29 /pmc/articles/PMC7341522/ /pubmed/32486015 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ani10060945 Text en © 2020 by the authors. Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
spellingShingle Article
Sardi, Luca
Gastaldo, Alessandro
Borciani, Marzia
Bertolini, Andrea
Musi, Valeria
Martelli, Giovanna
Cavallini, Damiano
Rubini, Giulia
Nannoni, Eleonora
Identification of Possible Pre-Slaughter Indicators to Predict Stress and Meat Quality: A Study on Heavy Pigs
title Identification of Possible Pre-Slaughter Indicators to Predict Stress and Meat Quality: A Study on Heavy Pigs
title_full Identification of Possible Pre-Slaughter Indicators to Predict Stress and Meat Quality: A Study on Heavy Pigs
title_fullStr Identification of Possible Pre-Slaughter Indicators to Predict Stress and Meat Quality: A Study on Heavy Pigs
title_full_unstemmed Identification of Possible Pre-Slaughter Indicators to Predict Stress and Meat Quality: A Study on Heavy Pigs
title_short Identification of Possible Pre-Slaughter Indicators to Predict Stress and Meat Quality: A Study on Heavy Pigs
title_sort identification of possible pre-slaughter indicators to predict stress and meat quality: a study on heavy pigs
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7341522/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/32486015
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/ani10060945
work_keys_str_mv AT sardiluca identificationofpossiblepreslaughterindicatorstopredictstressandmeatqualityastudyonheavypigs
AT gastaldoalessandro identificationofpossiblepreslaughterindicatorstopredictstressandmeatqualityastudyonheavypigs
AT borcianimarzia identificationofpossiblepreslaughterindicatorstopredictstressandmeatqualityastudyonheavypigs
AT bertoliniandrea identificationofpossiblepreslaughterindicatorstopredictstressandmeatqualityastudyonheavypigs
AT musivaleria identificationofpossiblepreslaughterindicatorstopredictstressandmeatqualityastudyonheavypigs
AT martelligiovanna identificationofpossiblepreslaughterindicatorstopredictstressandmeatqualityastudyonheavypigs
AT cavallinidamiano identificationofpossiblepreslaughterindicatorstopredictstressandmeatqualityastudyonheavypigs
AT rubinigiulia identificationofpossiblepreslaughterindicatorstopredictstressandmeatqualityastudyonheavypigs
AT nannonieleonora identificationofpossiblepreslaughterindicatorstopredictstressandmeatqualityastudyonheavypigs