Cargando…

Activated Regulatory T-Cells, Dysfunctional and Senescent T-Cells Hinder the Immunity in Pancreatic Cancer

SIMPLE SUMMARY: Pancreatic cancer has the worst survival of any human cancer. Checkpoint blockade has not yielded much benefit in pancreatic cancer. We explored immune cell phenotypes with this disease to identify new targets for checkpoint blockade therapy. We created a checkpoint-focused panel to...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Sivakumar, Shivan, Abu-Shah, Enas, Ahern, David J., Arbe-Barnes, Edward H., Jainarayanan, Ashwin K., Mangal, Nagina, Reddy, Srikanth, Rendek, Aniko, Easton, Alistair, Kurz, Elke, Silva, Michael, Soonawalla, Zahir, Heij, Lara R., Bashford-Rogers, Rachael, Middleton, Mark R., Dustin, Michael L.
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: MDPI 2021
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8068251/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33917832
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/cancers13081776
_version_ 1783682992287252480
author Sivakumar, Shivan
Abu-Shah, Enas
Ahern, David J.
Arbe-Barnes, Edward H.
Jainarayanan, Ashwin K.
Mangal, Nagina
Reddy, Srikanth
Rendek, Aniko
Easton, Alistair
Kurz, Elke
Silva, Michael
Soonawalla, Zahir
Heij, Lara R.
Bashford-Rogers, Rachael
Middleton, Mark R.
Dustin, Michael L.
author_facet Sivakumar, Shivan
Abu-Shah, Enas
Ahern, David J.
Arbe-Barnes, Edward H.
Jainarayanan, Ashwin K.
Mangal, Nagina
Reddy, Srikanth
Rendek, Aniko
Easton, Alistair
Kurz, Elke
Silva, Michael
Soonawalla, Zahir
Heij, Lara R.
Bashford-Rogers, Rachael
Middleton, Mark R.
Dustin, Michael L.
author_sort Sivakumar, Shivan
collection PubMed
description SIMPLE SUMMARY: Pancreatic cancer has the worst survival of any human cancer. Checkpoint blockade has not yielded much benefit in pancreatic cancer. We explored immune cell phenotypes with this disease to identify new targets for checkpoint blockade therapy. We created a checkpoint-focused panel to analyse immune cells from eight pancreatic cancer patients. This showed us the majority of T-cells are senescent. Further T-cell investigation demonstrated the majority of cytotoxic T-cells have intermediate to low PD1 expression suggesting why PD1 may not work as a pancreatic cancer therapy strategy. Our data has also highlighted a regulatory T-cell population which is highly activated and can mediate immunosuppression. The checkpoints that are highly expressed on these cells are TIGIT, ICOS and CD39, suggesting inhibition of these may be a viable therapeutic strategy. Furthermore, we showed that Tregs were retained amongst the fibroblast stroma of the tumour. Our work suggests there are key checkpoints on Tregs that may help guide therapeutic strategies in pancreatic cancer. ABSTRACT: Pancreatic cancer has one of the worst prognoses of any human malignancy and leukocyte infiltration is a major prognostic marker of the disease. As current immunotherapies confer negligible survival benefits, there is a need to better characterise leukocytes in pancreatic cancer to identify better therapeutic strategies. In this study, we analysed 32 human pancreatic cancer patients from two independent cohorts. A multi-parameter mass-cytometry analysis was performed on 32,000 T-cells from eight patients. Single-cell RNA sequencing dataset analysis was performed on a cohort of 24 patients. Multiplex immunohistochemistry imaging and spatial analysis were performed to map immune infiltration into the tumour microenvironment. Regulatory T-cell populations demonstrated highly immunosuppressive states with high TIGIT, ICOS and CD39 expression. CD8(+) T-cells were found to be either in senescence or an exhausted state. The exhausted CD8 T-cells had low PD-1 expression but high TIGIT and CD39 expression. These findings were corroborated in an independent pancreatic cancer single-cell RNA dataset. These data suggest that T-cells are major players in the suppressive microenvironment of pancreatic cancer. Our work identifies multiple novel therapeutic targets that should form the basis for rational design of a new generation of clinical trials in pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-8068251
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2021
publisher MDPI
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-80682512021-04-25 Activated Regulatory T-Cells, Dysfunctional and Senescent T-Cells Hinder the Immunity in Pancreatic Cancer Sivakumar, Shivan Abu-Shah, Enas Ahern, David J. Arbe-Barnes, Edward H. Jainarayanan, Ashwin K. Mangal, Nagina Reddy, Srikanth Rendek, Aniko Easton, Alistair Kurz, Elke Silva, Michael Soonawalla, Zahir Heij, Lara R. Bashford-Rogers, Rachael Middleton, Mark R. Dustin, Michael L. Cancers (Basel) Article SIMPLE SUMMARY: Pancreatic cancer has the worst survival of any human cancer. Checkpoint blockade has not yielded much benefit in pancreatic cancer. We explored immune cell phenotypes with this disease to identify new targets for checkpoint blockade therapy. We created a checkpoint-focused panel to analyse immune cells from eight pancreatic cancer patients. This showed us the majority of T-cells are senescent. Further T-cell investigation demonstrated the majority of cytotoxic T-cells have intermediate to low PD1 expression suggesting why PD1 may not work as a pancreatic cancer therapy strategy. Our data has also highlighted a regulatory T-cell population which is highly activated and can mediate immunosuppression. The checkpoints that are highly expressed on these cells are TIGIT, ICOS and CD39, suggesting inhibition of these may be a viable therapeutic strategy. Furthermore, we showed that Tregs were retained amongst the fibroblast stroma of the tumour. Our work suggests there are key checkpoints on Tregs that may help guide therapeutic strategies in pancreatic cancer. ABSTRACT: Pancreatic cancer has one of the worst prognoses of any human malignancy and leukocyte infiltration is a major prognostic marker of the disease. As current immunotherapies confer negligible survival benefits, there is a need to better characterise leukocytes in pancreatic cancer to identify better therapeutic strategies. In this study, we analysed 32 human pancreatic cancer patients from two independent cohorts. A multi-parameter mass-cytometry analysis was performed on 32,000 T-cells from eight patients. Single-cell RNA sequencing dataset analysis was performed on a cohort of 24 patients. Multiplex immunohistochemistry imaging and spatial analysis were performed to map immune infiltration into the tumour microenvironment. Regulatory T-cell populations demonstrated highly immunosuppressive states with high TIGIT, ICOS and CD39 expression. CD8(+) T-cells were found to be either in senescence or an exhausted state. The exhausted CD8 T-cells had low PD-1 expression but high TIGIT and CD39 expression. These findings were corroborated in an independent pancreatic cancer single-cell RNA dataset. These data suggest that T-cells are major players in the suppressive microenvironment of pancreatic cancer. Our work identifies multiple novel therapeutic targets that should form the basis for rational design of a new generation of clinical trials in pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma. MDPI 2021-04-08 /pmc/articles/PMC8068251/ /pubmed/33917832 http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/cancers13081776 Text en © 2021 by the authors. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/Licensee MDPI, Basel, Switzerland. This article is an open access article distributed under the terms and conditions of the Creative Commons Attribution (CC BY) license (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/).
spellingShingle Article
Sivakumar, Shivan
Abu-Shah, Enas
Ahern, David J.
Arbe-Barnes, Edward H.
Jainarayanan, Ashwin K.
Mangal, Nagina
Reddy, Srikanth
Rendek, Aniko
Easton, Alistair
Kurz, Elke
Silva, Michael
Soonawalla, Zahir
Heij, Lara R.
Bashford-Rogers, Rachael
Middleton, Mark R.
Dustin, Michael L.
Activated Regulatory T-Cells, Dysfunctional and Senescent T-Cells Hinder the Immunity in Pancreatic Cancer
title Activated Regulatory T-Cells, Dysfunctional and Senescent T-Cells Hinder the Immunity in Pancreatic Cancer
title_full Activated Regulatory T-Cells, Dysfunctional and Senescent T-Cells Hinder the Immunity in Pancreatic Cancer
title_fullStr Activated Regulatory T-Cells, Dysfunctional and Senescent T-Cells Hinder the Immunity in Pancreatic Cancer
title_full_unstemmed Activated Regulatory T-Cells, Dysfunctional and Senescent T-Cells Hinder the Immunity in Pancreatic Cancer
title_short Activated Regulatory T-Cells, Dysfunctional and Senescent T-Cells Hinder the Immunity in Pancreatic Cancer
title_sort activated regulatory t-cells, dysfunctional and senescent t-cells hinder the immunity in pancreatic cancer
topic Article
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8068251/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/33917832
http://dx.doi.org/10.3390/cancers13081776
work_keys_str_mv AT sivakumarshivan activatedregulatorytcellsdysfunctionalandsenescenttcellshindertheimmunityinpancreaticcancer
AT abushahenas activatedregulatorytcellsdysfunctionalandsenescenttcellshindertheimmunityinpancreaticcancer
AT aherndavidj activatedregulatorytcellsdysfunctionalandsenescenttcellshindertheimmunityinpancreaticcancer
AT arbebarnesedwardh activatedregulatorytcellsdysfunctionalandsenescenttcellshindertheimmunityinpancreaticcancer
AT jainarayananashwink activatedregulatorytcellsdysfunctionalandsenescenttcellshindertheimmunityinpancreaticcancer
AT mangalnagina activatedregulatorytcellsdysfunctionalandsenescenttcellshindertheimmunityinpancreaticcancer
AT reddysrikanth activatedregulatorytcellsdysfunctionalandsenescenttcellshindertheimmunityinpancreaticcancer
AT rendekaniko activatedregulatorytcellsdysfunctionalandsenescenttcellshindertheimmunityinpancreaticcancer
AT eastonalistair activatedregulatorytcellsdysfunctionalandsenescenttcellshindertheimmunityinpancreaticcancer
AT kurzelke activatedregulatorytcellsdysfunctionalandsenescenttcellshindertheimmunityinpancreaticcancer
AT silvamichael activatedregulatorytcellsdysfunctionalandsenescenttcellshindertheimmunityinpancreaticcancer
AT soonawallazahir activatedregulatorytcellsdysfunctionalandsenescenttcellshindertheimmunityinpancreaticcancer
AT heijlarar activatedregulatorytcellsdysfunctionalandsenescenttcellshindertheimmunityinpancreaticcancer
AT bashfordrogersrachael activatedregulatorytcellsdysfunctionalandsenescenttcellshindertheimmunityinpancreaticcancer
AT middletonmarkr activatedregulatorytcellsdysfunctionalandsenescenttcellshindertheimmunityinpancreaticcancer
AT dustinmichaell activatedregulatorytcellsdysfunctionalandsenescenttcellshindertheimmunityinpancreaticcancer