A versatile tRNA modification-sensitive northern blot method with enhanced performance

The 22 mitochondrial and ∼45 cytosolic tRNAs in human cells contain several dozen different post-transcriptional modified nucleotides such that each carries a unique constellation that complements its function. Many tRNA modifications are linked to altered gene expression, and deficiencies due to mutations in tRNA modification enzymes (TMEs) are responsible for numerous diseases. Easily accessible methods to detect tRNA hypomodifications can facilitate progress in advancing such molecular studies. Our laboratory developed a northern blot method that can quantify relative levels of base modifications on multiple specific tRNAs ∼10 yr ago, which has been used to characterize four different TME deficiencies and is likely further extendable. The assay method depends on differential annealing efficiency of a DNA-oligo probe to the modified versus unmodified tRNA. The signal of this probe is then normalized by a second probe elsewhere on the same tRNA. This positive hybridization in the absence of modification (PHAM) assay has proven useful for i(6)A37, t(6)A37, m(3)C32, and m(2,2)G26 in multiple laboratories. Yet, over the years we have observed idiosyncratic inconsistency and variability in the assay. Here we document these for some tRNAs and probes and illustrate principles and practices for improved reliability and uniformity in performance. We provide an overview of the method and illustrate benefits of the improved conditions. This is followed by data that demonstrate quantitative validation of PHAM using a TME deletion control, and that nearby modifications can falsely alter the calculated apparent modification efficiency. Finally, we include a calculator tool for matching probe and hybridization conditions.