Cargando…

The Association Between Distance Learning, Stress Level, and Perceived Quality of Education in Medical Students After Transitioning to a Fully Online Platform

Background: Before COVID-19, preclinical medical students traditionally attended didactic lectures in in-person settings. Due to social distancing, students were required to switch to online meeting platforms, such as Zoom. For medical students accustomed to in-person interactions, these changes may...

Descripción completa

Detalles Bibliográficos
Autores principales: Altaf, Rida, Kling, Michael, Hough, Arielle, Baig, Jibran, Ball, Andrea, Goldstein, Jessica, Brunworth, Jamie, Chau, Cassidy, Dybas, Marissa, Jacobs, Robin J, Costin, Joshua
Formato: Online Artículo Texto
Lenguaje:English
Publicado: Cureus 2022
Materias:
Acceso en línea:https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9097940/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35573543
http://dx.doi.org/10.7759/cureus.24071
_version_ 1784706274095529984
author Altaf, Rida
Kling, Michael
Hough, Arielle
Baig, Jibran
Ball, Andrea
Goldstein, Jessica
Brunworth, Jamie
Chau, Cassidy
Dybas, Marissa
Jacobs, Robin J
Costin, Joshua
author_facet Altaf, Rida
Kling, Michael
Hough, Arielle
Baig, Jibran
Ball, Andrea
Goldstein, Jessica
Brunworth, Jamie
Chau, Cassidy
Dybas, Marissa
Jacobs, Robin J
Costin, Joshua
author_sort Altaf, Rida
collection PubMed
description Background: Before COVID-19, preclinical medical students traditionally attended didactic lectures in in-person settings. Due to social distancing, students were required to switch to online meeting platforms, such as Zoom. For medical students accustomed to in-person interactions, these changes may add more stress to the already stressful medical school experience. Furthermore, it was unclear if students’ stress levels were related to their preference for one learning modality over another. The purpose of this study was thus to explore associations between lecture modality (synchronous Zoom lectures versus live, in-person lectures) and stress in second-year medical students after they transitioned from a face-to-face learning experience to a fully online lecture platform. Methodology: Cross-sectional data were collected from 112 second-year medical students enrolled in a large U.S. medical school using an anonymous questionnaire delivered electronically via social media and emails. The survey contained items pertaining to students’ attitudes towards different types of lecture modalities and how they relate to personal stress. Descriptive data and Spearman’s rank correlation tests were conducted using IBM Corp. Released 2020. IBM SPSS Statistics for Windows, Version 27.0. Armonk, NY: IBM Corp. Results: This study examined correlations between preclinical medical school lecture delivery and personality type, stress levels, attendance, and burnout. Overall, no significance was found between mode of delivery and personality type. On the other hand, the mode of delivery significantly affected stress levels, attendance, and burnout. Moderate to strong correlations were found between the item “Zoom lectures have reduced stress compared to in-person lectures” and preference for Zoom, quality of education using Zoom compared to the in-person lectures, belief that Zoom lectures should continue as part of the curriculum delivery method, staying motivated with lectures fully online with Zoom, and liking that Zoom lectures save commute time to campus. Conclusions: Findings suggest that a fully online curriculum may play a role in reducing stress in medical students without compromising the quality of education.
format Online
Article
Text
id pubmed-9097940
institution National Center for Biotechnology Information
language English
publishDate 2022
publisher Cureus
record_format MEDLINE/PubMed
spelling pubmed-90979402022-05-14 The Association Between Distance Learning, Stress Level, and Perceived Quality of Education in Medical Students After Transitioning to a Fully Online Platform Altaf, Rida Kling, Michael Hough, Arielle Baig, Jibran Ball, Andrea Goldstein, Jessica Brunworth, Jamie Chau, Cassidy Dybas, Marissa Jacobs, Robin J Costin, Joshua Cureus Medical Education Background: Before COVID-19, preclinical medical students traditionally attended didactic lectures in in-person settings. Due to social distancing, students were required to switch to online meeting platforms, such as Zoom. For medical students accustomed to in-person interactions, these changes may add more stress to the already stressful medical school experience. Furthermore, it was unclear if students’ stress levels were related to their preference for one learning modality over another. The purpose of this study was thus to explore associations between lecture modality (synchronous Zoom lectures versus live, in-person lectures) and stress in second-year medical students after they transitioned from a face-to-face learning experience to a fully online lecture platform. Methodology: Cross-sectional data were collected from 112 second-year medical students enrolled in a large U.S. medical school using an anonymous questionnaire delivered electronically via social media and emails. The survey contained items pertaining to students’ attitudes towards different types of lecture modalities and how they relate to personal stress. Descriptive data and Spearman’s rank correlation tests were conducted using IBM Corp. Released 2020. IBM SPSS Statistics for Windows, Version 27.0. Armonk, NY: IBM Corp. Results: This study examined correlations between preclinical medical school lecture delivery and personality type, stress levels, attendance, and burnout. Overall, no significance was found between mode of delivery and personality type. On the other hand, the mode of delivery significantly affected stress levels, attendance, and burnout. Moderate to strong correlations were found between the item “Zoom lectures have reduced stress compared to in-person lectures” and preference for Zoom, quality of education using Zoom compared to the in-person lectures, belief that Zoom lectures should continue as part of the curriculum delivery method, staying motivated with lectures fully online with Zoom, and liking that Zoom lectures save commute time to campus. Conclusions: Findings suggest that a fully online curriculum may play a role in reducing stress in medical students without compromising the quality of education. Cureus 2022-04-12 /pmc/articles/PMC9097940/ /pubmed/35573543 http://dx.doi.org/10.7759/cureus.24071 Text en Copyright © 2022, Altaf et al. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/3.0/This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
spellingShingle Medical Education
Altaf, Rida
Kling, Michael
Hough, Arielle
Baig, Jibran
Ball, Andrea
Goldstein, Jessica
Brunworth, Jamie
Chau, Cassidy
Dybas, Marissa
Jacobs, Robin J
Costin, Joshua
The Association Between Distance Learning, Stress Level, and Perceived Quality of Education in Medical Students After Transitioning to a Fully Online Platform
title The Association Between Distance Learning, Stress Level, and Perceived Quality of Education in Medical Students After Transitioning to a Fully Online Platform
title_full The Association Between Distance Learning, Stress Level, and Perceived Quality of Education in Medical Students After Transitioning to a Fully Online Platform
title_fullStr The Association Between Distance Learning, Stress Level, and Perceived Quality of Education in Medical Students After Transitioning to a Fully Online Platform
title_full_unstemmed The Association Between Distance Learning, Stress Level, and Perceived Quality of Education in Medical Students After Transitioning to a Fully Online Platform
title_short The Association Between Distance Learning, Stress Level, and Perceived Quality of Education in Medical Students After Transitioning to a Fully Online Platform
title_sort association between distance learning, stress level, and perceived quality of education in medical students after transitioning to a fully online platform
topic Medical Education
url https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9097940/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/35573543
http://dx.doi.org/10.7759/cureus.24071
work_keys_str_mv AT altafrida theassociationbetweendistancelearningstresslevelandperceivedqualityofeducationinmedicalstudentsaftertransitioningtoafullyonlineplatform
AT klingmichael theassociationbetweendistancelearningstresslevelandperceivedqualityofeducationinmedicalstudentsaftertransitioningtoafullyonlineplatform
AT hougharielle theassociationbetweendistancelearningstresslevelandperceivedqualityofeducationinmedicalstudentsaftertransitioningtoafullyonlineplatform
AT baigjibran theassociationbetweendistancelearningstresslevelandperceivedqualityofeducationinmedicalstudentsaftertransitioningtoafullyonlineplatform
AT ballandrea theassociationbetweendistancelearningstresslevelandperceivedqualityofeducationinmedicalstudentsaftertransitioningtoafullyonlineplatform
AT goldsteinjessica theassociationbetweendistancelearningstresslevelandperceivedqualityofeducationinmedicalstudentsaftertransitioningtoafullyonlineplatform
AT brunworthjamie theassociationbetweendistancelearningstresslevelandperceivedqualityofeducationinmedicalstudentsaftertransitioningtoafullyonlineplatform
AT chaucassidy theassociationbetweendistancelearningstresslevelandperceivedqualityofeducationinmedicalstudentsaftertransitioningtoafullyonlineplatform
AT dybasmarissa theassociationbetweendistancelearningstresslevelandperceivedqualityofeducationinmedicalstudentsaftertransitioningtoafullyonlineplatform
AT jacobsrobinj theassociationbetweendistancelearningstresslevelandperceivedqualityofeducationinmedicalstudentsaftertransitioningtoafullyonlineplatform
AT costinjoshua theassociationbetweendistancelearningstresslevelandperceivedqualityofeducationinmedicalstudentsaftertransitioningtoafullyonlineplatform
AT altafrida associationbetweendistancelearningstresslevelandperceivedqualityofeducationinmedicalstudentsaftertransitioningtoafullyonlineplatform
AT klingmichael associationbetweendistancelearningstresslevelandperceivedqualityofeducationinmedicalstudentsaftertransitioningtoafullyonlineplatform
AT hougharielle associationbetweendistancelearningstresslevelandperceivedqualityofeducationinmedicalstudentsaftertransitioningtoafullyonlineplatform
AT baigjibran associationbetweendistancelearningstresslevelandperceivedqualityofeducationinmedicalstudentsaftertransitioningtoafullyonlineplatform
AT ballandrea associationbetweendistancelearningstresslevelandperceivedqualityofeducationinmedicalstudentsaftertransitioningtoafullyonlineplatform
AT goldsteinjessica associationbetweendistancelearningstresslevelandperceivedqualityofeducationinmedicalstudentsaftertransitioningtoafullyonlineplatform
AT brunworthjamie associationbetweendistancelearningstresslevelandperceivedqualityofeducationinmedicalstudentsaftertransitioningtoafullyonlineplatform
AT chaucassidy associationbetweendistancelearningstresslevelandperceivedqualityofeducationinmedicalstudentsaftertransitioningtoafullyonlineplatform
AT dybasmarissa associationbetweendistancelearningstresslevelandperceivedqualityofeducationinmedicalstudentsaftertransitioningtoafullyonlineplatform
AT jacobsrobinj associationbetweendistancelearningstresslevelandperceivedqualityofeducationinmedicalstudentsaftertransitioningtoafullyonlineplatform
AT costinjoshua associationbetweendistancelearningstresslevelandperceivedqualityofeducationinmedicalstudentsaftertransitioningtoafullyonlineplatform