Wilms tumor reveals DNA repair gene hyperexpression is linked to lack of tumor immune infiltration

BACKGROUND: A T cell-rich tumor microenvironment has been associated with improved clinical outcome and response to immune checkpoint blockade therapies in several adult cancers. Understanding the mechanisms for lack of immune cell infiltration in tumors is critical for expanding immunotherapy efficacy. To gain new insights into the mechanisms of poor tumor immunogenicity, we turned to pediatric cancers, which are generally unresponsive to checkpoint blockade. METHODS: RNA sequencing and clinical data were obtained for Wilms tumor, rhabdoid tumor, osteosarcoma, and neuroblastoma from the Therapeutically Applicable Research to Generate Effective Treatments (TARGET) database, and adult cancers from The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA). Using an 18-gene tumor inflammation signature (TIS) representing activated CD8(+) T cells, we identified genes inversely correlated with the signature. Based on these results, adult tumors were also analyzed, and immunofluorescence was performed on metastatic melanoma samples to assess the MSH2 relationship to anti-programmed cell death protein-1 (PD-1) efficacy. RESULTS: Among the four pediatric cancers, we observed the lowest TIS scores in Wilms tumor. TIS scores were lower in Wilms tumors compared with matched normal kidney tissues, arguing for loss of endogenous T cell infiltration. Pathway analysis of genes upregulated in Wilms tumor and anti-correlated with TIS revealed activated pathways involved DNA repair. The majority of adult tumors in TCGA also showed high DNA repair scores associated with low TIS. Melanoma samples from an independent cohort revealed an inverse correlation between MSH2(+) tumor cells and CD8(+) T cells. Additionally, melanomas with high MSH2(+) tumor cell numbers were largely non-responders to anti-PD-1 therapy. CONCLUSIONS: Increased tumor expression of DNA repair genes is associated with a less robust immune response in Wilms tumor and the majority of TCGA tumor types. Surprisingly, the negative relationship between DNA repair score and TIS remained strong across TCGA when correcting for mutation count, indicating a potential role for DNA repair genes outside of preventing the accumulation of mutations. While loss of DNA repair machinery has been associated with carcinogenesis and mutational antigen generation, our results suggest that hyperexpression of DNA repair genes might be prohibitive for antitumor immunity, arguing for pharmacologic targeting of DNA repair as a potential therapeutic strategy.