Oncogenic and Receptor-Mediated Wnt Signaling Influence the Sensitivity of Colonic Cells to Butyrate

Deregulated Wnt signaling is responsible for most cases of colorectal cancer (CRC). Dietary fiber is protective against CRC and this activity is likely mediated by butyrate, a breakdown product of dietary fiber that hyperactivates Wnt signaling, repressing CRC proliferation and inducing apoptosis. Receptor-mediated Wnt signaling and oncogenic Wnt signaling, which is typically initiated by mutation in more downstream elements of the pathway, activate non-overlapping patterns of gene expression. Receptor-mediated signaling is associated with a poor prognosis for CRC while oncogenic signaling is associated with a relatively good prognosis. We have compared the expression of genes differentially expressed in receptor-mediated vs. oncogenic Wnt signaling to microarray data generated in our laboratory. Most importantly we evaluated these gene expression patterns comparing the early stage colon microadenoma line LT97 with the metastatic CRC cell line SW620. LT97 cells exhibit a gene expression pattern more strongly associated with that observed with oncogenic Wnt signaling, while SW620 cells exhibit a gene expression pattern moderately associated with that observed with receptor-mediated Wnt signaling. Given that SW620 cells are more advanced and malignant compared to LT97 cells, these findings are generally consistent with the better prognosis observed with tumors exhibiting a more oncogenic Wnt gene expression pattern. Importantly, LT97 cells are more sensitive to the effects of butyrate on proliferation and apoptosis that are CRC cells. We further examine these gene expression patterns in butyrate-resistant vs. butyrate-sensitive CRC cells. Based upon all of these observations, we hypothesize that colonic neoplastic cells exhibiting a more oncogenic as compared to receptor-mediated Wnt signaling gene expression pattern would be more sensitive to the effects of butyrate, and, hence, fiber, than are those cells exhibiting a more receptor-mediated Wnt signaling pattern of expression. Diet-derived butyrate may affect the differential patient outcomes resulting from the two types of Wnt signaling. We further posit that development of butyrate resistance and concomitant changes in Wnt signaling patterns, including associations with CBP and p300, disrupts the association between the two major types of Wnt signaling (receptor-mediated and oncogenic) and neoplastic progression/prognosis. Ideas about testing the hypothesis and therapeutic implications are briefly considered.